Every side of every story, in your inbox by 7am.Subscribe
Theme
Appearance
Subscribe

New Zealand votes in a two-Chris race that final polls called too close

Labour and National both polled near or under 31% before the 7 November vote, and a party that has never held a seat may decide the winner.

14 outlets28 headlines2 min read Blindspot for the right
Image: Reuters

The story

Labour polled 30.7% and National 26.4% in a final Infrastructure New Zealand poll, Reuters reported. A party that has never held a seat polled 5.1%.

  • New Zealand voted on Saturday, 7 November. Polls closed at 7 pm, SBS reported.
  • Prime Minister Christopher Luxon, 56, leads National. Chris Hipkins, 48, leads Labour and was prime minister for about 9 months in 2023.
  • Over 1.4 million people had voted early by mid-week, SBS reported.
  • “It is going to be close,” Luxon said, Reuters reported. Hipkins said Labour was “banking on being the biggest party in Parliament.”
  • A party needs 5% of the party vote or one electorate seat to enter parliament, SBS explained. There are 120 seats.
  • The Opportunity Party, led by Qiulae “Q” Wong, 38, polled 5.1%. It says it will work with either side. Luxon ruled out a deal with it, CNN reported.
  • Unemployment was 5.7% in the third quarter, the highest in 11 years, Reuters reported.
  • Polls disagreed. An October Roy Morgan poll had the governing bloc narrowly ahead, SBS reported. The reports we read were written before any result.

How each side told it

CNN led with the kingmaker. It ran: “A moderate millennial newcomer could decide knife-edge New Zealand election.” Its first nine paragraphs profiled Wong’s party. Its only voice was an academic, Lara Greaves, with no politician quoted. Paragraph 16 described the government as already very right-wing. CNN put Māori rights in paragraph 18. The Guardian ran: “New Zealand heads for election cliffhanger with minor party cast as kingmaker.” ABC Australia ran: “New Zealand election too close to call.” We could not open the Guardian or ABC pieces.

What got buried

Māori rights sat low or went missing. AP and Reuters left them out. CNN gave them one line, in paragraph 18. SBS, an Australian public broadcaster, covered them in paragraphs 33 to 36. It reported ACT’s plan to abolish the Waitangi Tribunal. It said results in the 7 Māori seats could shape coalition talks. AP’s lead was the shared first name, and it found room for baby-name data before any poll number. Unemployment at an 11-year high appeared in Reuters paragraph 14 and SBS paragraph 29.

Why it matters to you

If you live in or trade with New Zealand, the tax plans differ. Labour proposes a capital gains tax, CNN and SBS reported. The Greens propose taxes on the “super rich” and big tech, CNN said. The Opportunity Party backs a land tax and a universal basic income. At 5.1%, Opportunity sits 0.1 points above the line for seats. In a 120-seat parliament, 5% is worth about 6 seats. Those few seats could decide which bloc governs. If the coalition loses, it would be the first one-term government in over 50 years, Reuters reported.

The smallest party can hold the biggest vote.

All coverage

What we read to write this

Discussion

Be specific. Disagree with the framing, not the person.
Commenting is part of Pro. See Pro

Loading the discussion.