Every side of every story, in your inbox by 7am.Subscribe
Theme
Appearance
Subscribe

Shinde Sena tears pages of Sonia Gandhi's memoir, then a Bal Thackeray photo row

A protest over Savarkar lines in 'Belonging' turned when Shaina NC tore part of a 2004 photo. Both Sena camps now argue over what was torn.

18 outlets33 headlines2 min read
Image: Free Press Journal

The story

Shinde Sena leaders tore pages from Sonia Gandhi's memoir in Mumbai on 18 November and asked HarperCollins to drop pages 201 and 443. By evening, the row was about a torn photo of Bal Thackeray.

  • Sonia Gandhi's memoir, "Belonging: A Journey of Love," came out on 10 November, ANI reported. HarperCollins India published it.
  • Free Press Journal quoted a passage saying Savarkar was "writing mercy petitions to their colonial masters." PTI said the Sena also objected to a line calling RSS members British informers.
  • At a Mumbai press conference on 18 November, Shaina NC, Sanjay Nirupam and Anand Dubey tore pages, ANI reported. Nirupam said he expects the Maharashtra government to ban the book.
  • One prop was a 2004 photo of Bal Thackeray hitting an effigy of Mani Shankar Aiyar with a slipper, Outlook reported.
  • Shaina NC tore part of that photo. PTI called it inadvertent, and PTI-Bhasha said she quietly said "sorry." Later she said she would do it "a thousand times over."
  • Eknath Shinde said the torn part showed Aiyar's face. "I have seen it myself," he said, ANI reported.
  • Sanjay Raut of the Uddhav Thackeray Sena called them "fake sainiks," Outlook reported. UBT and MNS corporators walked out of a BMC meeting. Congress workers protested in Latur, PTI reported.
  • No report we read quoted the text of page 443.

How each side told it

The left led with the backfire. The Telegraph ran: "Shiv Sena protest against Sonia Gandhi's memoir backfires." Deccan Herald put a feud quote in its headline: "'Deserves public flogging'." Outlook opened on the photo row and quoted Raut first. It explained the 2004 photo only in its last two paragraphs. The Hindu's headline kept the original grievance: "tear pages of Sonia Gandhi's book over Savarkar references." So the left split between the protest and the misstep, with most of the weight on the misstep.

Missing context

The memoir passage makes two historical claims. The first is that Savarkar wrote mercy petitions to the British. That is on the record: he sent clemency petitions from the Andaman jail in 1911, 1913, 1917 and 1920. His 14 November 1913 petition says "I am ready to serve the government in any capacity they like" (R.C. Majumdar, Penal Settlements in Andamans, 1975, pp. 211-213). The second claim calls him one of the RSS's senior ideologues. Savarkar was president of the Hindu Mahasabha. The reference we read does not record him as an RSS member.

What got buried

Two details sat low. The first is the second objection. PTI's copy said the Sena also objected to the book calling RSS members British informers. It put this in paragraph 5. Most right headlines framed the row as Savarkar only. The second is why the photo was in the room. Outlook explained the 2004 "Jode Mara" protest against Aiyar in its last two paragraphs. Free Press Journal reported a second prop: a photo of Uddhav Thackeray holding the book.

Why it matters to you

A ban demand touches what you can buy and read in Maharashtra. Nirupam said he expects the state to ban the book. The reports we read show no state order so far. Under the shouting sits a history question you can check yourself. Savarkar's mercy petitions are on the record. Whether he was an RSS ideologue is a separate question. Two outlets quoted the same passage with slightly different words. Read the page itself before you share a torn copy of it.

A torn photo travels faster than the page it was about.

All coverage

What we read to write this

Discussion

Be specific. Disagree with the framing, not the person.
Commenting is part of Pro. See Pro

Loading the discussion.