Every side of every story, in your inbox by 7am.Subscribe
Theme
Appearance
Subscribe

India applies 162.5% duty and tax to bulk Scotch in first big UK trade pact dispute

Customs investigators class bulk whisky as a compound preparation taxed at 150% plus a consumption tax. The pact promised 75%.

11 outlets14 headlines2 min read
Image: Sunday Times (Reuters)

The story

Bulk Scotch now faces 162.5% in duty and tax at Indian ports, Reuters reported on 18 November. The India-UK pact, in force since 15 July, set the Scotch tariff at 75%.

  • The pact cut India's tariff on Scotch from 150% to 75%, falling to 40% by year 10, Reuters reported.
  • Customs investigators now place bulk concentrates under "compound alcoholic preparations," a category created in May, Reuters reported. That category carries 150%. A consumption tax adds the rest.
  • More than 80 containers belonging to Pernod, Diageo and Bacardi are held, Reuters reported. Firms can release them by paying 75% of the goods' value upfront and covering the rest with bank guarantees.
  • About 80% of UK Scotch reaches India in bulk, Reuters reported. Indian firms blend it into local whisky.
  • ANI said the Directorate of Revenue Intelligence found the concentrates arrive at 62% to 66% alcohol and are diluted later. ANI also said the probe "is not a new tariff increase."
  • Commerce Secretary Rajesh Agrawal said last week that India would "honour the duty concessions under the agreement," ANI reported.
  • Diageo shares fell 1.5% in London and Pernod's fell 1.25%, wine news site Vinetur reported.
  • The reports we read don't state the consumption tax rate. The 12.5 points is the gap between 162.5% and 150%.

How each side told it

The left framed it as a levy already in place. The Telegraph ran: "Scotch imports hit by 162.5% duty in India." It named Pernod and Diageo in the same headline. The Hindu ran: "India imposes 162.5% duty and tax on bulk Scotch imports." Deccan Herald used the softer Reuters wording: "India to charge bulk Scotch imports 162.5% duty." Two of the three named the UK pact. We could not read these three stories in full. So our reading of the left covers headlines only.

Missing context

The pact's tariff annex sets out how India's cuts work. Annex 2A, Section C, paragraph 1 defines India's base rate. It covers Basic Customs Duty, the agriculture infrastructure cess, the Health Cess and the Social Welfare Surcharge. Paragraph 2(q) defines the staging category "75%, R10 to 40%." Goods in it pay 75% when the pact takes effect. The rate then falls in nine equal yearly steps from 1 January of year two, reaching 40% from 1 January of year ten. A separate appendix assigns each tariff line to a category. We did not read that appendix, so we cannot confirm which lines bulk whisky sits on.

What got buried

The category's date sat low. Business Today's Reuters copy said the "compound alcoholic preparations" heading came in May. The pact took effect in July. So the classification was in place before the pact began. Business Today put this in paragraph 5. A confidential investigators' memo also cited "substantial revenue implications," a Reuters explainer said. In the reports we read, only that explainer carried the memo line.

Why it matters to you

About 80% of UK Scotch reaches India in bulk, and Indian firms blend it here. If the 162.5% holds, the import cost on that whisky is more than double the 75% the pact set. That is 162.5 divided by 75, about 2.2 times. An unnamed industry source said firms had already cut prices after the pact. Your bottle's final price also depends on state taxes, which vary. The finance ministry has not ruled on the classification in the reports we read.

A tariff cut is only as wide as its product code.

All coverage

What we read to write this

Discussion

Be specific. Disagree with the framing, not the person.
Commenting is part of Pro. See Pro

Loading the discussion.