Every side of every story, in your inbox by 7am.Subscribe
Theme
Appearance
Subscribe

Rahul Gandhi's 'lap' remark row: Shiva-Parvati post draws replies from Himanta and BJP

A childhood story at Sonia Gandhi's memoir launch turned into a two-day fight over religion and a Hoysala temple carving.

17 outlets34 headlines2 min read
Image: Asianet Newsable (ANI)

The story

A 12th-century temple carving became the centre of a political row within two days. It started with a childhood memory Rahul Gandhi shared at his mother's book launch on 16 November.

  • Sonia Gandhi launched her memoir, "Belonging: A Journey of Love," in New Delhi on 16 November.
  • Rahul Gandhi told a story from his childhood there. He said "there would be Papa, and on Papa's lap, there would be Mama," National Herald reported.
  • Assam Chief Minister Himanta Biswa Sarma posted a clip the same day. He wrote that Rahul "couldn't spare you the embarrassment," ThePrint reported.
  • On 17 November Rahul replied on X. He wrote that "fear, anger and hatred have woven a web" in BJP-RSS supporters. "As a true Hindu, it is my duty to free them from this web," he added. He posted a Hoysaleshwara temple carving of Shiva and Parvati, PTI reported.
  • Sarma replied: "To portray mortals as Shiva and Parvati is not devotion," ThePrint reported. The BJP's X account asked who broke the idols at Halebidu, naming invaders from 1311 and 1326-27.
  • Sources disagree on one point. PTI's first paragraph said Rahul compared his parents to Shiva and Parvati. His post shared the image without saying so.

How each side told it

Left outlets split on whom to put first. National Herald ran: "Rahul says fear & hatred keep BJP-RSS from expressing love." It quoted Rahul first and gave the Congress defence in paragraphs 4 to 7. The original remark came in paragraph 8. Sarma's first post came in paragraph 12. Halebidu did not appear in the version we read. Outlook went the other way and led with the BJP's Halebidu questions. It reached Rahul's original remark in its last two paragraphs, 21 and 22. The Telegraph asked: "'Belonging' or oversharing?"

What got buried

The order of events got lost. Sarma's first post came on 16 November, a day before Rahul's reply. It spoke to Sonia Gandhi directly: Rahul "couldn't spare you the embarrassment," he wrote. ThePrint put this in paragraph 7 of its analysis. National Herald put it in paragraph 12. The wire stories we read opened with the 17 November exchange. Read that way, Rahul looks like the one who struck first. Also low: ThePrint noted in paragraph 3 that the Halebidu temple is a UNESCO World Heritage site.

Why it matters to you

No bill, price or court date moved in this row. Count the words instead. Rahul's original remark was one family memory. The replies ran across at least five posts from three accounts over two days. That is the airtime a single anecdote bought. Before you share a clip like this, check the full line. National Herald printed Rahul's original words. ThePrint printed Sarma's first post. Both are short, and both change how the fight reads. The religious images now carry the story, so the memory itself is easy to miss.

The first post in a feud rarely leads the story.

All coverage

What we read to write this

Discussion

Be specific. Disagree with the framing, not the person.
Commenting is part of Pro. See Pro

Loading the discussion.