Every side of every story, in your inbox by 7am.Subscribe
Theme
Appearance
Subscribe

Sam Pitroda differs with Rahul Gandhi over phone-tapping charge against Modi

Rahul Gandhi said the Prime Minister taps his phone. Congress's Sam Pitroda said the PM "doesn't do it." Only right and center outlets ran headlines on the row.

8 outlets17 headlines2 min read Blindspot for the left
Image: The Federal

The story

Rahul Gandhi said Prime Minister Narendra Modi taps his phone. Sam Pitroda, who heads the Indian Overseas Congress, said the PM "doesn't take a screwdriver and get on a computer." We found 17 headlines on the row, none from left outlets.

  • On Friday, November 13, Congress shared a video of Rahul Gandhi on X, Pioneer and The Federal reported. Siasat said it came from an Instagram question session.
  • He said: "The proof is here. It's in this phone." He added, "The Prime Minister knows it because he taps my phone."
  • He renewed his call for a one-on-one public debate with Modi. He said his microphone is switched off in Parliament, Siasat reported.
  • None of the four reports we read describe any evidence beyond his words.
  • Pitroda told NDTV that the PM "doesn't do it." He said his own phone is tapped and his bank accounts are watched. "I don't know and I don't care," he said of who does it.
  • Rajeev Chandrasekhar of the BJP said, "Nobody is interested in tapping his phone," The Federal reported. Congress demanded an investigation, The Hans India reported.

How each side told it

The nine left-leaning outlets in our list ran no headline on the phone charge or on Pitroda that day. They did cover Rahul Gandhi. National Herald led with his Bharat Summit speech. The Telegraph ran two of his lines, about businessmen owning the government and gig workers as "partners in progress." A senior party figure publicly disagreed with him, and the left's headlines did not show it. We judged headlines only, so a mention inside a longer story is possible.

No left-leaning outlet we read ran this story.

What got buried

Two things got lost. The left left out the row itself, including Pitroda's break from his own leader. The right's headlines left out half of what Pitroda said. He said his own phone is tapped, his laptop is attacked and his bank accounts are watched. The Times of India's headline said he "dismisses" the claim. In the four reports we read, all four carried his own surveillance complaint. The Pioneer put it in paragraph 3. No headline in our list did.

Why it matters to you

Phone tapping touches your privacy, whoever the target is. Here, both public claims stand without shown proof. Rahul Gandhi said the proof is on his phone. Pitroda said experts warned him, and he named no one. Congress wants an inquiry. The BJP rejects the charge. Chirag Paswan said Rahul Gandhi wants the coming Parliament session washed out, per a ThePrint headline. Of 17 headlines on this row, 5 came from one channel and none came from the left. When you see a surveillance charge, ask one question first: what evidence was shown?

The more often a claim is repeated, the less checking it gets.

All coverage

What we read to write this

Discussion

Be specific. Disagree with the framing, not the person.
Commenting is part of Pro. See Pro

Loading the discussion.