Every side of every story, in your inbox by 7am.Subscribe
Theme
Appearance
Subscribe

Rahul Gandhi tells Hyderabad summit India is 'no longer a democracy'

At the Telangana-hosted Bharat Summit, Rahul Gandhi questioned the 2024 election. The BJP answered with charges about the summit's foreign guests.

20 outlets70 headlines3 min read
Image: The Federal

The story

Rahul Gandhi said on November 14 that India "is actually no longer a democracy." He asked how an election can be legitimate if the Election Commission treats 140 million voters as illegal, PTI reported.

  • The Telangana government hosted the Bharat Summit in Hyderabad. Rahul Gandhi spoke there on Saturday.
  • He said Congress had "found and proven" that India no longer works as a democracy, PTI reported. He dated the change to 2014.
  • He said people lose their voice when a few businessmen control the government, National Herald reported. He apologised to foreign delegates who could not attend and blamed the Union government.
  • Shashi Tharoor said that 115 of 315 cleared foreign speakers were denied entry or lost visas, The Federal reported. The foreign ministry said visa decisions are a sovereign matter.
  • BJP media convener Ashish Usha Agarwal linked guest Guillaume Long, a former Ecuador foreign minister, to groups funded by Soros-backed entities, The Federal reported.
  • Giacomo Filibeck of the Party of European Socialists used the slogan "Vote chor, gaddi chhod" on stage, Organiser reported. Telangana BJP chief N Ramchander Rao asked on X if this was treason.
  • The 140 million figure is Rahul Gandhi's own. None of the four reports we read checked it against Election Commission data.

How each side told it

The left led with his words. National Herald ran: "India 'no longer a democracy' under BJP rule, says Rahul Gandhi at Bharat Summit". Its story carried his call for truth and non-violence and his line about businessmen. It gave no BJP reply in the version we read. The Wire chose his warmest phrase: "Indian Democracy a Global Public Good". Deccan Herald led with the voter rolls, calling the 2024 vote "under a cloud." The BJP's reply ran under separate Deccan Herald headlines. On the left, the speech and the answer to it rarely shared a page.

What got buried

The visa numbers sat low everywhere. In the four reports we read, only The Federal gave Tharoor's count of 115 barred speakers out of 315, in paragraph 16. It put the foreign ministry's answer in paragraph 17. PTI mentioned the absent delegates in its last two paragraphs, with no number. National Herald carried a figure of 113 only in a link to another story. Organiser did not mention the barred guests. So the one checkable government action at the summit got the least space, and the two numbers we found do not match.

Why it matters to you

This fight is about voter lists, and voter lists decide who gets to vote. In Uttar Pradesh, the roll fell from 15.44 crore to 13.39 crore names after the recent revision, ThePrint reported. That is 2.05 crore fewer names, about 13% of the old list. Both parties now argue over who those people were. Rahul Gandhi's 140 million figure may include such removals, but the reports we read do not show his math. The visa dispute touches a different right: which outside voices you get to hear. Your own name on the roll is the one fact here you can check yourself.

A speech and its rebuttal are rarely printed side by side.

All coverage

What we read to write this

Discussion

Be specific. Disagree with the framing, not the person.
Commenting is part of Pro. See Pro

Loading the discussion.