Every side of every story, in your inbox by 7am.Subscribe
Theme
Appearance
Subscribe

Modi opens Bengaluru Pink Line stretch as Karnataka disputes the metro cost split

PM Modi opened a 7.5 km, Rs 3,470 crore metro stretch. CM Shivakumar used the same stage to say states pay over 80% of metro costs.

21 outlets76 headlines3 min read
Image: Deccan Chronicle (PTI)

The story

Prime Minister Narendra Modi opened a 7.5 km, Rs 3,470 crore stretch of Bengaluru's Pink Line on 13 November. On the same stage, Chief Minister D.K. Shivakumar said Karnataka pays far more than its half of metro costs.

  • The new elevated stretch has 6 stations and cost about Rs 3,470 crore, PTI reported. Public service began at 6 am on 14 November.
  • The full Pink Line will run 21.25 km with 18 stations. Its 12 underground stations are still being built, PTI said.
  • Modi said Bengaluru's network is now over 100 km, up from about 17 km in 2014, IANS reported. ANI and The Pioneer put it past 103 km.
  • He also launched projects worth over Rs 15,600 crore, IANS reported. Two paragraphs later, the same report said over Rs 15,000 crore.
  • Shivakumar handed Modi a memorandum. It said states carry more than 80% of metro costs despite a 50:50 split, ANI reported. He also sought Rs 22,400.58 crore in drought relief, PTI reported.
  • BJP MP Tejasvi Surya disagreed. He put the Centre's share of Namma Metro costs at 53.35%, Swarajya reported. Karnataka minister Krishna Byre Gowda had put it at 16.2%.
  • The reports we read don't say how Modi answered the funding demands.

How each side told it

The left split between the ride and the demands. Outlook ran the PTI story: "PM Modi Inaugurates Metro's Pink Line In Bengaluru, Travels Along With CM Shivakumar." It led with the cost and the two men buying tickets. The funding demands did not appear in the version we read. The Hindu put the dispute in its headline: "Chief Minister D.K. Shivakumar places Karnataka's demands on stage with Prime Minister." Deccan Herald quoted Shivakumar asking Modi for a "fair deal." We could not read the full Hindu or Deccan Herald stories, so we can't say what they put low.

What got buried

The numbers behind the dispute sat low. Surya says the Centre paid Rs 41,558 crore. Karnataka says Rs 12,600 crore. The gap is Rs 28,958 crore. Swarajya, in paragraphs 6 and 7, put foreign loans for the project at about Rs 28,958 crore. So the fight may come down to who gets credit for those loans. No report we read set the two figures side by side. The Western Ghats also sat low. Shivakumar asked the Centre to drop a draft notice under the Kasturirangan report covering 20,668 sq km in 1,449 villages. ANI carried it in paragraph 9. The PTI stories we read left it out.

Why it matters to you

If you ride Namma Metro, 7.5 km of new track opened to the public on 14 November, PTI reported. Twelve more stations on the same line are still being built. The cost fight decides who pays for the next lines. Shivakumar asked for a 500 km network and approval of the Red Line from Sarjapur to Hebbal, ANI reported. Here is the gap in rupees. Surya puts the Centre's share at Rs 41,558 crore. Karnataka puts it at Rs 12,600 crore. Both figures come from the same Rs 77,891 crore total. Whichever is right, the money comes from taxes you pay to one government or the other.

When both sides cite one total, check what each one counted.

All coverage

What we read to write this

Discussion

Be specific. Disagree with the framing, not the person.
Commenting is part of Pro. See Pro

Loading the discussion.