Every side of every story, in your inbox by 7am.Subscribe
Theme
Appearance
Subscribe

MEA calls visas 'sovereign' after Tharoor says 115 Bharat Summit speakers were barred

Congress leaders said foreign speakers for a Hyderabad summit lost their visas. The MEA gave no reason, and no one has checked the count independently.

19 outlets35 headlines2 min read
Image: Siasat

The story

Congress MP Shashi Tharoor said 115 of 315 foreign speakers for Hyderabad's Bharat Summit were refused entry or lost their visas. The foreign ministry answered in one line and gave no reason.

  • The Bharat Summit ran on 13 and 14 November at HITEX in Hyderabad, ThePrint and Outlook reported. ThePrint said about 1,000 delegates from about 70 countries were invited.
  • Who runs it is disputed. The Pioneer called it organised by the Congress. Outlook said the Telangana government organises it, and Congress leader Gurdeep Sappal called it a state event.
  • Tharoor said 115 speakers cleared by the MEA were "refused entry or had visas cancelled." He said this was "apparently" on Home Ministry orders.
  • MEA spokesperson Randhir Jaiswal said: "Visa matters are sovereign functions of any country or any government." He gave no reason, ThePrint and The Pioneer reported.
  • Norwegian journalist Helle Lyng Svendsen said India's Oslo embassy called her about 10 minutes before she left for the airport, Outlook reported.
  • In the reports we read, no one had checked the 115 figure independently. The Home Ministry had not responded.

How each side told it

The left led with the 115 number. The Wire ran: "After 115 Bharat Summit Speakers Denied Entry, MEA Says..." That headline states the denials as fact. Scroll attributed the count: "denied entry into India, claims Shashi Tharoor." Outlook quoted Tharoor first and opened its summary with the Norwegian journalist. In paragraph 12 it mentioned a planned think tank, the "Our World Institute." A second Outlook story quoted Telangana CM Revanth Reddy first and put the state's investment summit in paragraphs 9 and 10. We read only the Outlook texts in full.

What got buried

Two details bear on the loudest charges, and both sat low. BJP leaders called the event anti-India. ThePrint, in paragraph 18, carried Congress's statement that no Chinese Communist Party members or parties from neighbouring countries were invited. In the reports we read, only ThePrint carried it. BRS leader KTR said the summit used Rs 100 crore of public money. Siasat, in paragraph 4, gave an RTI figure for the first edition: Rs 29.45 crore. No report we read gave an audited cost for this year.

Why it matters to you

If you live in Telangana, part of this event is paid from state funds. The only documented cost is Rs 29.45 crore for the first edition, from an RTI reply cited by Siasat. KTR put this year at Rs 100 crore. That leaves a gap of Rs 70.55 crore, and neither side has shown an audit. The visa question touches press access too. The Editors Guild of India voiced "deep concern" about the Norwegian journalist, ThePrint reported. Without a stated reason, you cannot tell whether the 115 refusals followed a rule. For now, the MEA's one line is the whole official record.

A decision without a reason lets every side supply one.

All coverage

What we read to write this

Discussion

Be specific. Disagree with the framing, not the person.
Commenting is part of Pro. See Pro

Loading the discussion.