Every side of every story, in your inbox by 7am.Subscribe
Theme
Appearance
Subscribe

Sonia Gandhi's memoir 'Belonging' draws BJP attacks on 1984 and the Emergency

The BJP called the book a whitewash. Congress called it a personal story. Few headlines quoted what the book itself says about 1984.

20 outlets117 headlines3 min read
Image: Siasat (PTI)

The story

On 11 November, a day after Sonia Gandhi's memoir came out, the BJP called it a whitewash. The same Wednesday, the book topped Amazon India's bestseller list, Reuters reported.

  • Sonia Gandhi's memoir, "Belonging: A Journey of Love", was released on Tuesday, 10 November. It runs to more than 500 pages, The Week reported.
  • HarperCollins India published it after talks with Penguin Random House India failed, Reuters reported. It costs Rs 1,299.
  • The Week reported that the book says the BJP and RSS put India's democracy at risk. She writes that she and Modi have had almost no real talks in over 12 years.
  • On Wednesday, BJP spokesperson Sudhanshu Trivedi said she gave up the PM post in 2004 and became a "super PM." He pointed to her Cabinet-rank NAC post during UPA rule, PTI reported.
  • Trivedi also disputed her claim that Rajiv Gandhi opposed the Emergency. He said the book has "many technical mistakes", including the year of the Anna Hazare movement.
  • BJP spokesperson CR Kesavan said in a video statement that the book should have been called "Whitewashing", Reuters reported. He cited the 1984 anti-Sikh riots, in which nearly 3,000 people were killed.
  • Congress leaders said the BJP was giving the book a "political spin", Reuters reported. A Congress spokesperson did not answer Reuters. Gandhi has not responded to the charges.

How each side told it

The left mixed her own words with the BJP's attacks. Deccan Herald ran: "It's her story, not your version": Sam Pitroda slams BJP criticism of Sonia memoir. It also ran her line "Ground has shifted under Modi govt's feet" as a headline. Outlook led with the personal side: her food, her cancer treatment and her 2004 call to the DMK. The Hindu ran a review called "A memoir of revelation and reticence." These outlets did carry the BJP side. Deccan Herald ran the "Super PM" dig and a "pack of lies" charge from P V Narasimha Rao's grandson. None of the left headlines we saw mentioned the BJP's list of factual errors.

What got buried

No headline we saw, on either side, quoted what the book says about 1984. Reuters carried it in paragraph 8. Gandhi calls the riots a "tragic and shameful chapter." She writes that some officials looked away or fuelled the violence. In paragraph 9, Reuters reported that she defends Rajiv Gandhi against complicity charges. She also admits governance failures and delayed justice. ANI's headline on Sukhbir Badal called the book a "clean chit." A smaller detail sat low too. Trivedi said the Anna Hazare movement began in 2011, while the book says 2012. The Week's summary of the book also says 2012.

Why it matters to you

The book lands before two state elections. Polls in Uttar Pradesh and Sikh-majority Punjab are due early next year, Reuters reported. Several attacks on the 1984 chapter came from Punjab leaders, including Sukhbir Badal and Harsimrat Badal. The book costs Rs 1,299, which Reuters called expensive. A pirated PDF was circulating two days after release, a Tribune headline said. So most people will meet this book through quotes someone else picked. Each side picked different pages. If you care about 1984 or the Emergency, read those chapters yourself. Then check the dates against the record.

Every quoted page is a page someone chose for you.

All coverage

What we read to write this

Discussion

Be specific. Disagree with the framing, not the person.
Commenting is part of Pro. See Pro

Loading the discussion.