Kharge called Diwali an 'Eid of happiness', and BJP and Congress fought over one word
BJP leaders called the greeting appeasement. Congress said Eid literally means festival. Most coverage ran the attack before the defence.

The story
Mallikarjun Kharge's Diwali greeting used one word, Eid, and drew 32 headlines from right-leaning outlets in our list on November 9. Nine of them came from India Today alone.
- Kharge, the Congress president, gave Diwali greetings to reporters on November 7.
- He called the festival "khushiyon ka Eid," an Eid of happiness. His message also stressed unity and harmony, one report said.
- BJP spokespersons said the remark showed appeasement and hurt Hindu sentiments. Gaurav Bhatia asked what was wrong with calling Diwali by its own name. Pradeep Bhandari called it "blatant appeasement."
- BJP leaders dared Kharge and Rahul Gandhi to call Eid a "Diwali of joy."
- Congress leader Pawan Khera defended Kharge. He said critics were "semantically ignorant," since the word Eid literally means festival.
- The reports we read don't say whether Kharge himself answered the criticism.
How each side told it
Left-leaning outlets gave the defence more room. National Herald ran: "Kharge's remark makes sense to linguists." Deccan Herald led with Congress, which it said "says word 'Eid' literally means festival." The Hindu ran the attack: "BJP attacks Mallikarjun Kharge over 'Eid of joy' Deepavali greeting." Outlook and The Hindu also carried the BJP dare in their titles. Of the 5 left headlines we found, National Herald was the one built around the language point.
Missing context
The defence rests on a claim about language. Merriam-Webster traces the English word Eid to the Arabic names of the two Islamic festivals: 'id al-fitr, "Festival of the Breaking of the Fast", and 'id al-adha, "Festival of the Sacrifice". In both names, 'id is the word rendered as "festival". The dictionary dates the first known English use of Eid to 1698. This supports Khera's point about what the word means. It does not settle how the greeting was meant or heard, which is a matter of opinion.
What got buried
The meaning of the word got the least space. Eid literally means festival, Pawan Khera said, and a dictionary check backs the word's origin. In the 49 headlines we found on this row, 5 carried that point: National Herald, Deccan Herald, ANI, The Tribune and the Times of India. The second buried detail is Kharge's full message. One report we read said it also stressed unity and harmony. None of the 49 headlines mentioned that part.
Why it matters to you
This row does not change a law, a price or a service you use. It does take space. On November 9, it drew 49 headlines across the outlets we track. On the same day, Parliament's record 88-day prorogation delay, which Congress links to bills on delimitation, drew 13. When a word fight leads the news, check what else ran that day. You can read the greeting yourself and decide what it meant.
The smaller the word, the bigger the fight can get.
All coverage
Congress defends Mallikarjun Kharge's remark on Diwali, says word 'Eid' literally means festival
BJP sees red over ‘khushiyon ki Eid’, but Kharge's remark makes sense to linguists
BJP Slams Kharge For Calling Diwali 'Eid Of Joy', Dares Congress To Call Eid 'Diwali Of Joy'
BJP attacks Mallikarjun Kharge over “Eid of joy” Deepavali greeting
BJP Attacks Congress Over Kharge’s ‘Eid of Happiness’ Remark on Diwali
‘Diwali is Diwali, Eid is Eid’: BJP slams Mallikarjun Kharge over festival remark | India News
BJP Slams Mallikarjun Kharge’s ‘Diwali Ek Khushiyon Ki Eid’ Remark | Kharge On Diwali
"Khushiyon Ki Eid": M Kharge's Diwali Greeting Draws BJP's Appeasement Charge
BJP accuses Congress of appeasement politics after Kharge’s ‘Diwali an Eid of happiness’ remark
Congress hits back at BJP over Kharges khushiyon ka Eid remark, calls critics semantically ignorant
"Anti-Sanatan mindset": BJP launches all-out offensive over Kharge calling Diwali 'Eid of happiness'; Congress mounts fiery counterattack
Gaurav Bhatia slams Kharge over Diwali-Eid remark
BJP criticises senior Congress leaders for controversial statements at major Hindu festivals - India Today
'Khushiyon Ki Eid' For Diwali? Congress Faces Questions Over Kharge's Festive Greeting | Hard Facts
‘Diwali is Eid of happiness’: Remarks by Kharge exposes Congress unease with Hindu identity
'Might Start Crying': BJP's Gaurav Bhatia Takes Swipe At Kharge Over 'Eid Of Happiness' Remark On Diwali
'Anti-Hindu, Anti-Sanatan': BJP Mounts Attack On Kharge Over Diwali 'Khushiyon Ki Eid' Remark
‘Rahul Gandhi’s Bhopu’: BJP Takes Aim At Cong Over Kharge’s ‘Eid Of Happiness’ Diwali Remark
What we read to write this
- ThePrint (PTI) BJP hits out at Kharge for calling Diwali 'Eid of joy', dares Congress to call Eid 'Diwali of joy'
- Outlook BJP Slams Kharge For Calling Diwali 'Eid Of Joy', Dares Congress To Call Eid 'Diwali Of Joy'
- Siasat 'Eid means festival': Congress defends Kharge amid BJP attack
- Asianet Newsable (ANI) BJP attacks Mallikarjun Kharge over 'Eid of happiness' Diwali remark
Loading the discussion.