Every side of every story, in your inbox by 7am.Subscribe
Theme
Appearance
Subscribe

Karnataka says petrol held up to 31.2% ethanol, and oil firms and the Centre dispute it

Karnataka stood by its tests on November 9 and Keralam began sampling petrol. Oil companies said 893 samples met the E20 standard.

15 outlets25 headlines2 min read
Image: Siasat

The story

Karnataka says some petrol sold as E20 held up to 31.2% ethanol. The oil companies say 893 samples from 27 states and Union Territories met the standard, and the Centre backs them.

  • Karnataka's food and civil supplies minister, Rizwan Arshad, said his department tested 63 petrol samples. He said results showed ethanol up to 31.2%, above the 20% E20 blend.
  • IOCL, BPCL and HPCL rejected the claim and questioned the testing method. They said 893 samples from 27 states and UTs, including 56 from Karnataka, met the IS 17021 standard.
  • Karnataka said the companies' lab reports did not give ethanol percentages. On November 9, Arshad said the state stood by its results and asked why the companies certify their own samples.
  • Union minister Pralhad Joshi called the claims "a classic case of choosing sensationalism over responsible governance." He said sample densities of 0.752 to 0.760 g/cc ruled out blends above 20%.
  • Keralam began collecting samples the same day in Thiruvananthapuram, Ernakulam, Kozhikode and Kannur. Reports put the number of outlets at six to nine. Results were expected within about 10 days.
  • Congress workers protested at Karnataka petrol pumps, Deccan Chronicle and ThePrint reported.
  • The reports we read don't include an independent lab result on these samples.

How each side told it

Left-leaning outlets led with Karnataka's stand. Deccan Herald ran Arshad's line: "'Karnataka stands by E20 results'." The Telegraph wrote that "Congress ups ante on E20" and put Keralam's checks in the same headline. National Herald ran: "Karnataka challenges OMCs over ethanol." Deccan Herald also carried Joshi's charge of "attention diversion." The oil companies' 893-sample figure did not appear in the 9 left headlines we found.

What got buried

The size of each test sat low on both sides. Karnataka tested 63 samples. The oil companies cited 893 across 27 states and UTs, including 56 from Karnataka. In the 25 headlines we found, none set those numbers side by side. A second detail got little space. A Karnataka statement asked the Centre for an independent verification framework if it disputes the findings. Two outlets, Deccan Chronicle and The Hindu, put that call in their headlines.

Why it matters to you

If your car runs on E20, the real blend matters for mileage. Karnataka's minister asked for a price cut over mileage loss, News18 reported. Karnataka also asked for an ethanol display at every pump and a fund to cover fuel damage claims. None of this is in place in the reports we read. Keralam's results are due in about 10 days. Until then, you have two sets of tests and no neutral lab.

When each side tests itself, ask who tests both.

All coverage

What we read to write this

Discussion

Be specific. Disagree with the framing, not the person.
Commenting is part of Pro. See Pro

Loading the discussion.