Every side of every story, in your inbox by 7am.Subscribe
Theme
Appearance
Subscribe

Sonia Gandhi's memoir draws BJP attacks over Babri, Emergency and 1984 lines

Excerpts and interviews tied to 'Belonging' covered Rajiv Gandhi, the Gita, Babri and the Emergency. Right-leaning outlets ran most of the headlines.

9 outlets12 headlines3 min read Blindspot for the left
Image: Siasat (PTI)

The story

Sonia Gandhi said she cried watching the Babri Masjid demolition "on television," in an interview tied to her memoir. Of the 9 outlets with memoir headlines in our 8 November list, 5 lean right and 1 leans left.

  • The memoir is "Belonging: A Journey of Love." HarperCollins India publishes it in India, with release on 10 November, Siasat and ThePrint reported.
  • In an extract The Guardian published, she said she pleaded with Rajiv Gandhi not to become prime minister after Indira Gandhi's assassination in 1984. She warned they would kill him too, IANS reported.
  • She wrote that she was "caught in a war with myself" over entering politics, and turned to the Bhagavad Gita, PTI reported.
  • In The Guardian interview, she said the demolition signalled "a long battle for the secular nation." She also said "we have been too complacent in many ways," PTI reported.
  • She called the 1975 Emergency "a mistake" and said Indira came to feel the same, Outlook reported. In The Hindu interview, she also said "it was done constitutionally."
  • BJP MP Sudhanshu Trivedi said Babar "was, and still is, in the Congress's heart," PTI reported. He questioned which channel she watched on 6 December 1992.
  • BJP's Tarun Chugh told her to take off her "Italian lenses" and write about the 1984 anti-Sikh riots, PTI reported.
  • Penguin Random House India said it is not the book's Indian publisher. Congress had alleged pressure to cut passages, Free Press Journal reported in August. FPJ found no independent evidence of pressure.

How each side told it

One left outlet in our list ran a memoir headline that day. The Telegraph ran: "Sonia Gandhi bares Penguin 'unease' over 'criticism of government' in memoir." It led with the publisher row. Outlook, also on the left in our list, ran two pieces we read. Its Emergency piece led with "a mistake" and carried no BJP reaction. The "done constitutionally" line sat in about paragraph 9. Its second piece was PTI copy, led by Trivedi's attack. Deccan Herald, The Hindu and National Herald had no memoir headline in our 8 November list.

What got buried

Left-leaning outlets mostly skipped this story. In our 8 November list, only The Telegraph ran a memoir headline on the left. The right ran 8. Inside the coverage, her self-criticism sat low. In the PTI copy Outlook ran, her line "we have been too complacent in many ways" came in about paragraph 5. The BJP's "Babar" quote led. No headline we read carried it. The publisher detail also got muddled. The Telegraph's headline named Penguin. HarperCollins India is the Indian publisher, per PTI and ThePrint.

Why it matters to you

The book goes on sale in India on 10 November, per Siasat and ThePrint. You can read the passages in full yourself. Most quotes in this round came from two interviews, one with The Guardian and one with The Hindu. The Emergency lines show why the source matters. Outlook led with "a mistake." PTI and Republic led with "done constitutionally." Both are her words, from different settings. Read the full answer before you share a clip of it.

A quote is only as true as its setting.

All coverage

What we read to write this

Discussion

Be specific. Disagree with the framing, not the person.
Commenting is part of Pro. See Pro

Loading the discussion.