Every side of every story, in your inbox by 7am.Subscribe
Theme
Appearance
Subscribe

Supreme Court issues contempt notice to Kerala Congress over post on CJI Surya Kant

A two-judge bench sent notices to all KPCC office-bearers over a deleted X post that told the Chief Justice to resign.

15 outlets16 headlines2 min read
Image: LawBeat

The story

A deleted post on Kerala Congress's X account told Chief Justice Surya Kant to "resign now." On November 6, the Supreme Court sent contempt notices to every office-bearer of the state unit.

  • On October 12, the @INCKerala account posted: "Dear Surya Kant, If law and order is not your domain, resign now." The post was later deleted.
  • Madhyamam reported what came before it. The Chief Justice had called protests against the Election Commission a law and order matter, outside his subject.
  • Advocate Vineet Jindal filed a complaint on October 13. The court treated it as a writ petition on October 30, Outlook reported.
  • On November 6, Justices Aravind Kumar and Vipul M Pancholi issued show-cause notices to all KPCC office-bearers. The bench refused a request to limit the notice to the party president, LawBeat reported.
  • PTI quoted the bench: free speech "can't be a shield of intimidation" against the administration of justice.
  • KPCC's counsel said the post went up without the leaders' knowledge. The party deleted it, removed the person responsible and gave an unconditional apology.
  • Senior advocates Arvind Datar and Siddharth Agarwal will assist the court. South First reported the next hearing as December 15. The other reports we read don't give a date.

How each side told it

Left-leaning outlets led with the court. Deccan Herald's headline quoted the bench: "Constitution is supreme, no organisation above it." The Wire's headline described the post as "Asking CJI to Resign." Outlook quoted the bench first, in paragraph 2. It gave KPCC's defence in paragraph 4 and the apology in paragraph 7. Outlook did not quote the post itself. Its readers learned the post existed without reading its words. We could not open the body text at The Wire or Deccan Herald.

Missing context

Article 129 of the Constitution says the Supreme Court is a court of record with "the power to punish for contempt of itself." Section 2(c) of the Contempt of Courts Act, 1971 defines criminal contempt. It covers any publication that "scandalises or tends to scandalise" a court or lowers its authority. It also covers acts that interfere with the administration of justice "in any other manner."

What got buried

Two details got little space. The first is the remark that started it. The Chief Justice had said "Ye mera vishay nahin hai" (this is not my subject) about the protests. Only Madhyamam carried it, in paragraphs 3 and 4. The second is reach. KPCC's own counsel said the post drew about 10 million views, LawBeat reported in paragraph 10. Also, "Constitution supreme" and "no party above Constitution" were paraphrases in the PTI copy we read. Deccan Herald and News18 put them in quotation marks.

Why it matters to you

This case tests where criticism of a judge turns into contempt. That line applies to anyone who posts about courts, including you. Under the Contempt of Courts Act, 1971, criminal contempt includes publishing words that lower a court's authority. The bench said it will weigh both civil and criminal contempt. KPCC says it deleted the post and apologised. The court will decide if that is enough. If you post about a judge, you can criticise the ruling and its reasoning. Telling a judge to quit has now drawn a contempt notice.

The sharper the post, the closer it sits to the law.

All coverage

What we read to write this

Discussion

Be specific. Disagree with the framing, not the person.
Commenting is part of Pro. See Pro

Loading the discussion.