Every side of every story, in your inbox by 7am.Subscribe
Theme
Appearance
Subscribe

Karnataka says petrol held up to 31.2% ethanol, oil companies reject its tests

Karnataka said most petrol samples it tested broke the 20% E20 limit. IOCL, BPCL and HPCL said the sampling broke the rules.

18 outlets19 headlines3 min read
Image: Newslaundry

The story

Karnataka said a petrol sample from IOCL held 31.2% ethanol. The limit for E20 petrol is 20%, so that sample ran 11.2 percentage points over, by the state's count.

  • Karnataka's Food and Civil Supplies Minister Rizwan Arshad released the findings at a press conference on Friday, November 6.
  • The state's Legal Metrology Department collected 63 petrol samples from seven districts, including Bengaluru, Kolar and Tumakuru, The News Minute reported.
  • The samples first went to the in-house labs of IOCL and BPCL. Those reports left out the ethanol figure, the state said. "This made us suspicious," Arshad said.
  • The state then used the Shriram Research Institute in Bengaluru. South First reported that 11 of 14 tested samples were above 20%. The highest were IOCL at 31.2% and HPCL at 30.5%.
  • Karnataka asked for a probe, ethanol levels shown at every pump and a compensation fund for vehicle owners.
  • On November 7, IOCL, BPCL and HPCL rejected the findings in a joint statement. They said their petrol meets the BIS standard IS 17021. They said the samples were taken without their staff present, against the sampling rules.
  • They cited national tests of 893 samples, 56 of them from Karnataka. The Karnataka samples averaged 19.30% ethanol, the companies said.
  • The reports we read don't explain how 63 samples collected became 14 samples tested.

How each side told it

Left-leaning outlets led with the state's numbers. The Wire ran "Not E20, But E31.2" and put the words "Petrol Chori" in its headline. Newslaundry carried The News Minute's report, which opened with the allegation and quoted Arshad first. That report had no response from the oil companies. The Centre's general defence of E20 came near the end, in paragraph 20 of the original. Outlook's headline said Karnataka "Finds Levels As High As 31.2%." We could not open The Wire's body text. On this side, the state's lab result was the story.

What got buried

The low readings got little space. South First listed three samples under 20%, in paragraph 6. Shell came in at 13.5%, BPCL at 19.9% and MRPL at 19.2%. In the reports we read, only South First gave them. The companies' 893-sample figure also sat low. It came in paragraph 9 at Swarajya and paragraph 12 at The Week. The first-day reports we read, from PTI, The News Minute and South First, did not have it. Each side's best number arrived on a different day.

Why it matters to you

Karnataka put the cost to drivers at about Rs 1.01 lakh crore a year. That is Rs 62,000 crore in lost mileage plus Rs 39,000 crore in repairs, by the state's estimate. The oil companies do not accept the test results behind it. Both sides agree on the rule: E20 petrol should hold close to 20% ethanol. The state has asked for the level to be shown at every pump. The reports we read don't say if the Centre will agree. If your mileage drops, keep the pump name and date from your receipt. A complaint needs that detail.

A lab result is only as strong as its sampling.

All coverage

What we read to write this

Discussion

Be specific. Disagree with the framing, not the person.
Commenting is part of Pro. See Pro

Loading the discussion.