Every side of every story, in your inbox by 7am.Subscribe
Theme
Appearance
Subscribe

Jharkhand minister's '40 lakh youth' remark draws BJP fire, gets no left headlines

Irfan Ansari said 40 lakh youths awaited an order and warned of unrest like Bangladesh and Nepal. Center and right outlets covered it, left ones did not.

9 outlets14 headlines2 min read Blindspot for the left
Image: The Hans India (IANS)

The story

Jharkhand minister Irfan Ansari said "40 lakh youths are on the streets." Nine outlets ran headlines on the remark on November 6. None of them was left-leaning.

  • Irfan Ansari, a Congress minister in Jharkhand, spoke in Delhi on Thursday, November 5.
  • PTI reported he was answering questions on the Centre's Agniveer decision and on Rahul Gandhi's remarks about the US midterms.
  • "As many as 40 lakh youths are on the streets," he said, in PTI's translation. He said they needed only an order. He added that they "will not go beyond Rahul Gandhi."
  • He said farmers, the middle class, Dalits, Adivasis and Muslims were distressed. PTI said he warned of events "worse than in Bangladesh and Nepal" if Modi did not act.
  • On November 6, BJP president Nitin Nabin wrote on X: "Rahul Gandhi ji, the nation demands answers from you." JD(U) and LJP(RV) leaders also criticised the remark, PTI reported.
  • The Pioneer said Congress had issued no official statement. Congress leader Udit Raj told IANS: "Our path is one of non-violence."
  • The reports we read carry no clarification from Ansari himself.

How each side told it

Left-leaning outlets in our set ran no headline on Ansari's remark on November 6. We searched The Wire, Scroll, National Herald and Deccan Herald and found no story. The Hindu ran "Congress wants to spread anarchy in the name of democracy: Bhupender Yadav." We could not open it, so we can't say whether it named Ansari. The closest thing to a defence came from IANS, a wire service. It quoted Congress's Udit Raj first, in paragraphs 2 and 3. Ansari's words came in paragraph 18.

No left-leaning outlet we read ran this story.

What got buried

Ansari's own limit sat in the middle of his quote. He said the youths "will not go beyond Rahul Gandhi," in ThePrint's PTI copy, paragraph 4. Organiser carried it as paraphrase. The setting came later still. PTI put the Agniveer and midterm questions in paragraph 7, after his quotes. Organiser, The Pioneer and The Week left that out. His list of distressed groups, from farmers to Muslims, was in ThePrint's paragraph 5. Organiser and The Pioneer did not carry it.

Why it matters to you

A minister's words carry weight because he holds office. Here, the exact words are hard to pin down. PTI translated one line as "an emergency is bound to happen." Organiser translated it as "an emergency-like situation will emerge." No outlet we read linked a full video or transcript. That matters if you plan to share a clip or a quote. Check the original language and the question asked. In this case, the question was about Agniveer and the US midterms, PTI said. Udit Raj of Congress questioned the 40 lakh figure, IANS reported.

The less you see of the source, the louder the quote gets.

All coverage

What we read to write this

Discussion

Be specific. Disagree with the framing, not the person.
Commenting is part of Pro. See Pro

Loading the discussion.