Every side of every story, in your inbox by 7am.Subscribe
Theme
Appearance
Subscribe

Traders' body CAIT writes to Rahul Gandhi over Delhi market disruption

Right-leaning outlets ran the letter widely, and no left outlet we track did. Few noted that CAIT's secretary general is a BJP MP.

10 outlets10 headlines2 min read Blindspot for the left
Image: ThePrint (ANI)

The story

The Confederation of All India Traders sent Rahul Gandhi five questions on 5 November about rallies in Delhi. None of the 10 left-leaning outlets we track ran a headline on it.

  • The INDIA bloc rallied at Ramlila Maidan on 1 November against the voter-roll revision and the CEC. Delhi Traffic Police diverted traffic from 10 am to 5 pm, Open reported.
  • On 5 November, CAIT wrote to Rahul Gandhi, PTI reported. It cited road blockades and protests over the past month, during the festive and wedding season.
  • CAIT national president B C Bhartia said, "Rahul Gandhi cannot hold two contradictory positions simultaneously," The Week reported.
  • The letter asked whether the right to protest outweighs the right to trade. It also asked who would pay traders for losses, ANI reported.
  • It asked that protests be held at sites away from markets, PTI reported.
  • CAIT said it would hold a nationwide 'Dhikkar Diwas' after Diwali. The date will be fixed at a traders' meeting once Gandhi replies.
  • The letter gave no loss figure. A separate body, the Chamber of Trade and Industry, estimated Rs 11,000 crore for the 1 November rally, The Week reported.
  • Open called such projections unverified.
  • The reports we read carried no Congress response to the letter.

How each side told it

The left did not run the letter. Of the 10 left-leaning outlets we track, none carried a headline on it. A targeted search by our researchers found no left story either. Left outlets wrote about the rally itself instead. The Hindu ran "INDIA bloc's November 1 Ramlila Maidan rally | Explainer." The Wire asked "Are Huge Anti-SIR Crowds at Ramlila Maidan Enough to Stall the Process?" Those pieces covered the protest's cause. Left readers saw no story about traders' complaints over its cost.

No left-leaning outlet we read ran this story.

Missing context

The letter set the right to trade, Article 19(1)(g), against free speech, Article 19(1)(a). The Constitution of India lists both in Article 19(1), along with the right "to assemble peaceably and without arms" in Article 19(1)(b). Both come with limits. Article 19(3) lets the state impose reasonable restrictions on assembly in the interests of public order or India's sovereignty and integrity. Article 19(6) allows reasonable restrictions on trade in the interests of the general public. The text of Article 19 does not rank one of these rights above the other.

What got buried

The signatory's network sat out of view. CAIT's secretary general, Praveen Khandelwal, is a BJP MP from Chandni Chowk, a Delhi market seat, News24 reported on 1 November. In the five letter reports we read, none said so. News On AIR named him only as secretary general. The other buried detail is Gandhi's earlier reply. On 26 October he posted, "To every trader in Delhi: We love you and hear you," OneIndia reported. No letter story we read included it.

Why it matters to you

If you trade or shop in central Delhi, the cost estimate is the number to watch. The Chamber of Trade and Industry put it at Rs 11,000 crore for one rally day. Of that, Rs 8,800 crore was retail and wholesale within 5 km of Ramlila Maidan, The Week reported. That leaves Rs 2,200 crore for everything else in the estimate. Open called such figures projections that were not independently checked. The Dhikkar Diwas date is still unset. You can weigh any loss estimate by asking who made it and how.

Who signs a letter is part of the letter's news.

All coverage

What we read to write this

Discussion

Be specific. Disagree with the framing, not the person.
Commenting is part of Pro. See Pro

Loading the discussion.