Every side of every story, in your inbox by 7am.Subscribe
Theme
Appearance
Subscribe

Officials tell House the week's tech outages were not a coordinated attack

DNI Jay Clayton and DHS Secretary Markwayne Mullin faced bipartisan questions over five outages and Mullin's flight to a college football game.

39 outlets210 headlines3 min read
Image: Fox News

The story

A Republican lawmaker counted five major US system failures in under a week. On Wednesday, the nation's top intelligence official told Congress they had “different causes.”

  • The House Homeland Security Committee held its annual Worldwide Threats hearing on Wednesday, November 18.
  • DHS Secretary Markwayne Mullin, Director of National Intelligence Jay Clayton and FBI Deputy Director Christopher Raia testified, CNN and The Hill reported.
  • Rep. Nick LaLota, a New York Republican, listed the failures: Microsoft 365, the FAA ground stop, United, Chase and Wells Fargo, and the NSA, The Hill reported.
  • Clayton called them “separate service outages associated with maintenance and technical changes,” Fox News reported. Mullin said he was “98% confident” there was no malicious activity, CNN reported.
  • Clayton pointed to a rise in software patches and upgrades. The Hill reported in paragraph 14 that he labeled his view an “informed opinion.”
  • The FAA has blamed a faulty router, and Apple has blamed an internal update, Fox News reported on its live blog. For Chase and Microsoft, the reports we read don't say.
  • Lawmakers also pressed Mullin on his Saturday flight on a government plane to the LSU-Texas game, a day after the ground stop. He said he repaid the cost, CNN and NBC reported.
  • FBI Director Kash Patel did not attend. The FBI said he was visiting field offices.
  • No shared root cause has been publicly confirmed.

How each side told it

The left led with the people in the room. CNN ran: “Mullin defends flight as he bears brunt of lawmakers' ire during threats hearing.” Its story quoted Mullin's “98% confident” line first, in paragraph 2. The flight took paragraphs 8 to 10. Patel's absence came at paragraphs 25 to 28. NBC's live blog gave the flight its own post. It quoted Rep. Bennie Thompson calling the trip “incredibly tone deaf.” NBC's headline stuck to the 98% figure. Both outlets put the human drama near the top and the technical causes lower.

What got buried

One set of numbers sat in one report. The Hill wrote that the Cybersecurity and Infrastructure Security Agency, or CISA, had 3,400 staff when the administration began. By June it had 2,200, though it needs 2,800, Rep. James Walkinshaw said. That appears in paragraphs 20 and 21. Mullin would not call the cuts a mistake, The Hill reported. In the four reports we read, only The Hill carried the staffing figures. CNN and Fox both framed the story around cyber readiness and left them out.

Why it matters to you

The outages hit flights, banks and phones, services you likely use every week. Here is the staffing math from The Hill's figures. CISA went from 3,400 staff to 2,200. That is 1,200 fewer people, about 35% of the starting staff. The agency's stated need of 2,800 is still 600 more than it had in June. The FAA has paused router installs, Fox News reported. You can watch for each company's own cause report. Until those arrive, “different causes” remains an informed opinion from the witness table.

A calm answer and a confirmed cause are two different things.

All coverage

What we read to write this

Discussion

Be specific. Disagree with the framing, not the person.
Commenting is part of Pro. See Pro

Loading the discussion.