Every side of every story, in your inbox by 7am.Subscribe
Theme
Appearance
Subscribe

Supreme Court turns away Maryland 'sensitive places' gun case as Thomas voices doubts

No justice dissented from the denial in Novotny v. Moore. Thomas agreed with it, but wrote that many such bans may lack historical support.

12 outlets12 headlines2 min read
Image: The Federalist

The story

Maryland's bans on carrying guns in places like schools, parks and public transit stay in force. The Supreme Court declined the challenge on Monday, CBS News reported, and no justice dissented.

  • The case is Novotny v. Moore, MS NOW and the Federalist reported.
  • The challengers targeted 10 categories of places, CBS reported. Older Maryland laws cover school property, public demonstrations, public transit, parks, museums and casinos.
  • A 2023 law added day care and medical facilities and government buildings, CBS said.
  • A federal district court blocked the limits on demonstrations and places serving alcohol. The 4th Circuit then upheld all the challenged rules, CBS reported.
  • On Monday, Nov. 16, the court denied the case without giving a reason, Just the News reported.
  • Justice Clarence Thomas agreed with the denial because the challenge was too broad. He wrote of "serious doubts" that tradition supports "many of these sweeping restrictions."
  • Maryland Attorney General Anthony Brown cited a "rich American tradition" of gun bans in "confined and crowded" places, CBS reported.
  • CBS gave no date or vote count for the 4th Circuit ruling.

How each side told it

MS NOW led with Thomas. Its headline: "Clarence Thomas has 'serious doubts' about gun restrictions in 'sensitive places.'" The denial itself came second. In paragraph 5, it noted Thomas wrote the 2022 Bruen decision and that lower courts find its test confusing. Paragraph 9 raised talk of Thomas or Alito retiring after Democrats won the Senate. Raw Story's headline said Thomas "declares war" after colleagues "hang him out to dry." In the reports we read, Thomas agreed with the denial. MS NOW did not give Maryland's defense or the lower court history.

What got buried

Maryland's side of the case got little room. Only CBS quoted Attorney General Anthony Brown, in paragraphs 14 and 15. Only CBS laid out the lower court rulings, in paragraphs 9 to 11. In the four reports we read, MS NOW, the Federalist and Just the News left out both. All three made Thomas the first person quoted. A reader of those three would learn the most about one justice's view. They would learn the least about why the law still stands.

Why it matters to you

If you carry a gun in Maryland, the 4th Circuit ruling that upheld these rules stays in place, CBS reported. That covers schools, parks, public transit, museums and casinos. It also covers day care, medical sites and government buildings under the 2023 law. If you live in another state, watch Thomas's words. He wrote, "In an appropriate case, this Court should consider" these limits, the Federalist reported. The Federalist said AR-15 cases are set for argument in weeks. You can read Thomas's full statement in the court's Monday order list.

Who gets quoted first shapes what a ruling seems to mean.

All coverage

What we read to write this

Discussion

Be specific. Disagree with the framing, not the person.
Commenting is part of Pro. See Pro

Loading the discussion.