Fetterman calls a Van Hollen win 'troubling' as Schumer leadership race heats up
Fetterman told Fox News a Van Hollen win could push him from the party. The left covered the backlash, and the right covered the threat.

The story
Sen. Chris Van Hollen needs a simple majority of Senate Democrats in a secret ballot to unseat Chuck Schumer. On Saturday, Sen. John Fetterman said a Van Hollen win could push him out of the party.
- Van Hollen, a Maryland Democrat, announced Thursday that he will challenge Schumer for Senate Democratic leader, Fox News reported.
- "To deliver, we need new leadership," he wrote, Newsweek reported.
- Newsweek listed four public backers: Sens. Bernie Sanders and Jeff Merkley and incoming Sens. Abdul El-Sayed and Peggy Flanagan. Van Hollen called himself "the underdog." Schumer reportedly believes he has enough support.
- Democrats will hold at least 55 Senate seats next year. The vote is set for Dec. 1, The New York Times reported.
- On Fox News on Saturday, Fetterman said a Van Hollen win would be "troubling." He called Van Hollen hostile to Israel.
- Asked if this was a red line, Fetterman said "Yeah, absolutely," Newsweek reported. He also said he does not see a path for Van Hollen to win, Fox reported.
- The reports we read don't give a full count of Schumer's backers.
How each side told it
The left led with Van Hollen's bid and the backlash to Fetterman. The New York Times ran: "Van Hollen Says He Will Challenge Schumer for Senate Majority Leader." MS NOW ran: "Van Hollen says he's gaining ground on Chuck Schumer for Senate leader." Raw Story ran: "Cheers as Fetterman reveals what will make him leave Dem Party." Raw Story gave paragraphs 6 to 13 to social media replies, mostly from critics. A DNC vice chair wrote, "We don't care." We read the Times and MS NOW headlines only. So the left told a story about momentum.

The Case Against Chuck SchumerThe New Republic
Van Hollen Says He Will Challenge Schumer for Senate Majority LeaderThe New York Times

What got buried
Van Hollen's actual Israel votes sat low. Newsweek gave them in paragraphs 5 and 6. In November 2024, he backed resolutions to block some offensive weapons sales to Israel. He said he still supported Iron Dome, a defense system. In March, he joined efforts to block nearly $659 million in offensive arms sales. In the 3 reports we read, only Newsweek gave these details. Fox and Raw Story both relayed Fetterman's charge without the record behind it.
Why it matters to you
The math is short. Half of 55 is 27.5, so a winner needs at least 28 of 55 votes if every Democrat votes. Newsweek listed four public backers for Van Hollen. By that count, he needs 24 more by Dec. 1. The fight also touches war money. Van Hollen said Congress should give "not one penny more" for war with Iran, the Times reported. Congress faces a Dec. 11 deadline to fund the government. That is 10 days after the leader vote. If a shutdown would affect your job or benefits, watch both dates.
The person quoted first often decides what the story is about.
All coverage
How Chris Van Hollen’s bid to replace Chuck Schumer as Senate Majority Leader could unfold
The Case Against Chuck Schumer
Week in Politics: Battle for Senate leader; young and independent midterm turnout
Van Hollen Says He Will Challenge Schumer for Senate Majority Leader
Cheers as Fetterman reveals what will make him leave Dem Party: 'I'm embarrassed for you'
Fox News Corners Fetterman on What Will Make Him Go Republican
Fetterman Says Van Hollen as Senate Leader Would Be ‘Troubling’
John Fetterman Signals Breaking Point With Democrats Over Van Hollen
Fetterman: Naming Van Hollen majority leader ‘would be troubling’
Fetterman warns there is no longer 'common ground' with far-left Democrats over Israel
Schumer Allies Predict 40-Plus Votes Against Van Hollen
Inside the DSA campaign to destroy ‘ultra-Zionists’ Schumer and Jeffries
John Fetterman Isn't Too Happy With Chris Van Hollen's Senate Leadership Bid
‘Stage one’ of DSA takeover starts with ousting Chuck Schumer: Joe Concha
Fetterman says he might leave Dems if Van Hollen is elected Senate leader
What we read to write this
- Newsweek John Fetterman Signals Breaking Point With Democrats Over Van Hollen
- Fox News Fetterman warns there is no longer 'common ground' with far-left Democrats over Israel
- Raw Story Cheers as Fetterman reveals what will make him leave Dem Party: 'I'm embarrassed for you'
- The New York Times (via Boston Globe) Van Hollen says his Senate challenge to Schumer is gaining support
Loading the discussion.