US home sales fall to a 3.75 million pace in October, the slowest since 2010
Sales fell 5.5% from September as mortgage rates averaged 7.33%, and each side picked a different main cause.

The story
Americans bought existing homes at a 3.75 million annual pace in October, the slowest since August 2010. The National Association of Realtors released the figure on Nov. 12.
- Sales fell 5.5% from September and 8.8% from a year earlier, AP reported. Economists polled by FactSet expected 3.8 million.
- The median price was $416,700, up 0.4% from a year earlier, AP said. That is a record for October.
- First-time buyers made up 29% of sales, down from 32% a year earlier. AP put the historical norm near 40%.
- There were 1.59 million homes for sale, a 5.1-month supply, AP said.
- The 30-year mortgage rate averaged 7.33% in October, NAR said, citing Freddie Mac. A year earlier it was 6.25%.
- The West fell hardest, down 14.5% from a year earlier, NAR said.
- NAR chief economist Lawrence Yun said "there could be sizable pent-up demand if mortgage rates decline."
- These are closed sales. Many were signed in August and September, when rates ran 6.65% to 7.03%, AP noted.
How each side told it
The left made it a story about rates and the Fed. NPR ran: "'Punch in the gut': Homes sales fall to their lowest in 16 years." NPR quoted one person, Joel Berner of Realtor.com. It framed the slowdown as partly the Fed's aim. Berner said "getting inflation under control is really the goal." NPR left out the 5.5% monthly drop, the median price and first-time buyers. The Guardian ran: "US home sales hit 16-year low in October amid soaring mortgage rates." Both headlines pointed to rates as the cause.

Home Sales Fall to 16-Year Low as Mortgage Rates Remain HighThe New York Times

What got buried
The Iran war sat low or out. AP said rates dipped below 6% before the US-Iran war began in late February. Since then they peaked at 7.4%, AP said in paragraphs 9 and 10. NPR and the Daily Caller did not mention the war in the versions we read. AP also carried the 40% first-time buyer norm. In the three news reports we read, only AP gave it. Both details help explain who is being priced out, and why now.
Why it matters to you
Here is what the rate change does to a payment, using the $416,700 median price. Assume 20% down, a loan of $333,360. Those assumptions are ours. At 6.25%, a 30-year loan costs about $2,053 a month in principal and interest. At 7.33%, it costs about $2,292. That is about $240 more a month, or about $2,870 a year, by our math. The price itself rose 0.4%, or about $1,660. The rate change costs more than that within a year. If you are shopping, run your own payment at today's rate before you compare prices.
A home's price and its monthly cost are different numbers.
All coverage
'Punch in the gut': Homes sales fall to their lowest in 16 years
Home Sales Fall to 16-Year Low as Mortgage Rates Remain High
US home sales hit 16-year low in October amid soaring mortgage rates
US home sales slumped in October to slowest pace in more than 16 years as mortgage rates surged
US home sales slumped in October to slowest pace in more than 16 years as mortgage rates surged
Sales of Existing US Homes Tumble to Lowest Level Since 2010
US existing home sales slump to more than 16-year low in October
Home Sales in October Plummet to 16-Year Low
Home Sales Dropping Like A Rock, Reach 16-Year Lows
Home Sales Slump 5.5% to Slowest Pace in 16 Years
Home sales plunge to 16-year low as mortgage rates stay high: ‘Just a tough market’
U.S. home sales slumped in October to slowest pace in more than 16 years as mortgage rates surged
What we read to write this
- Associated Press (via Anchorage Daily News) US home sales slumped in October to slowest pace in more than 16 years as mortgage rates surged
- National Association of Realtors Existing-Home Sales Decreased 5.5% in October
- NPR (via OPB) 'Punch in the gut': Homes sales fall to their lowest in 16 years
- The Daily Caller Home Sales Dropping Like A Rock, Reach 16-Year Lows
Loading the discussion.