Every side of every story, in your inbox by 7am.Subscribe
Theme
Appearance
Subscribe

ICE reports record 483,200 deportations in fiscal 2026 as outlets debate the baseline

DHS said arrests and removals hit records, while outlets differed on the comparison year and on how many deportees had criminal records.

16 outlets17 headlines2 min read
Image: Reason

The story

ICE deported 483,200 people in the fiscal year that ended Sept. 30, DHS said on Nov. 12. That is 9% above the prior record of 442,640, AP reported.

  • DHS released the figures in a press release on Thursday, Nov. 12.
  • ICE made more than 491,000 arrests, CBS News reported. About 475,000 were civil immigration arrests. August set a monthly record with 50,925.
  • Fiscal 2024, under President Biden, saw 271,484 deportations. This year is 78% higher, CBS reported.
  • "ICE has been unleashed to target and remove illegal aliens," DHS Secretary Markwayne Mullin said, per AP.
  • The White House goal is 1 million deportations a year, AP said.
  • Trump told "60 Minutes" that "I think it was too tough," CBS reported.
  • Outlets picked different baselines. AP compared with 405,090 under Obama in 2014. CBS used 409,849 in 2012. Reason, citing TRAC data, said fiscal 2009 was higher, at 489,251.
  • AP noted that DHS has largely stopped publishing regular data, which makes outside checks hard.

How each side told it

The left paired the record with the politics. CBS News ran: "ICE deportations and arrests hit record high as Trump faces reckoning." CBS said voters are divided in its first paragraph. It gave its exit poll: 58% said enforcement went "too far." CBS also ran its own analysis: 6% of people booked into detention had violent-crime convictions. Politico ran: "ICE touts record deportations as polls show voters soured on Trump's crackdown." HuffPost's headline used "Brags" and "Midterm Bloodbath." So the left chose verbs like "touts" and "brags" and put voter mood beside the count.

What got buried

Who was deported sat low on both sides. AP gave the criminal-record share in paragraph 15. It said about a quarter had convictions in July, citing the Deportation Data Project. CBS gave its 6% violent-crime figure in paragraph 16. It also cited the Migration Policy Institute, which put the share with a criminal conviction near 20%. The Daily Wire gave no share in the version we read. Voluntary departures got less space. In the four reports we read, only Reason carried the 37% figure.

Why it matters to you

A 2025 law gave $75 billion to ICE and $45 billion for detention, CBS reported. That is $120 billion in total. CBS said the target is about 19,000 arrests a week. Times 52 weeks, that is about 988,000 a year, by our math. That sits close to the White House goal of 1 million deportations. Arrests and deportations are different counts, so the match is rough. AP reported that two US citizens were killed in confrontations with officers. When an agency picks its own comparison year, check the one it skipped.

A record depends on the year you start counting from.

All coverage

What we read to write this

Discussion

Be specific. Disagree with the framing, not the person.
Commenting is part of Pro. See Pro

Loading the discussion.