Every side of every story, in your inbox by 7am.Subscribe
Theme
Appearance
Subscribe

House shelves Massie's Hegseth impeachment 211-204 as 18 members skip the vote

Eleven Democrats and 7 Republicans did not vote. Coverage on both sides focused on the Democrats.

30 outlets88 headlines2 min read
Image: KSNV

The story

The House voted 211-204 on Nov. 10 to shelve Rep. Thomas Massie's impeachment of Defense Secretary Pete Hegseth. Eleven Democrats skipped the vote, and so did 7 Republicans.

  • Massie, a Republican, filed a 34-page resolution with 8 articles on Nov. 9, Stars and Stripes reported. The House had to act within 2 legislative days.
  • On Nov. 10, the House voted 211-204 to send it to the Judiciary Committee, AP and Fox News reported. That move shelves it. Massie was the only Republican to vote no.
  • Eleven Democrats and 7 Republicans did not vote, Common Dreams and Drop Site reported.
  • Four Democrats blamed traffic or a police escort, Spectrum News reported. Rep. Steven Horsford cited a "personal emergency," KSNV reported. Pelosi's office said she was at a Veterans Day event in San Francisco.
  • Drop Site reported that 4 of the 11 attended an Elect Democratic Women reception. Reports differ on Rep. Lou Correa. The Daily Beast cited a medical procedure, and Drop Site reported a heart attack.
  • Sources also differ on the charges. AP tied them to the Iran war. The Daily Wire listed Iran, Yemen, Venezuela, the Caribbean and Sen. Mark Kelly.
  • Rep. Pettersen expects another vote in January, Scripps reported.

How each side told it

Left-leaning outlets led with Democrats' own absences. HuffPost ran: "Democrats Tear Into Their Own After 11 No-Shows Derail Hegseth Impeachment Bid." The Daily Beast went further: "Jaw-Dropping Reasons 11 Dems Botched Impeaching Hegseth Are Exposed." Its story opened on the traffic excuse and quoted a Democratic chief of staff first. MS NOW called the vote "a Democratic debacle." The 211 Republicans who voted to shelve it got less space than the 11 who stayed away. The left's story was about its own side.

What got buried

The 7 absent Republicans got far less space than the 11 Democrats. If all 11 Democrats had voted no, the motion would have failed 211-215, Scripps and Spectrum News reported. Add the 7 Republicans as yes votes, and it passes 218-215. That second sum is our math from the reported counts. Common Dreams gave the Republican count in paragraph 6. In the reports we read, AP, Fox News and the Daily Wire left it out.

Why it matters to you

A House vote is decided by who shows up. Seven votes separated the two sides on Nov. 10. Four of the absent Democrats blamed traffic. The shelved articles can come back, and Pettersen expects a vote in January, Scripps reported. AP tied GOP midterm losses to the Iran war and rising gas prices, without giving figures. If you want to know what your own member did, USA Today and CNN each ran a member-by-member list. Check it before you weigh anyone's excuse, from either party.

Attendance is a vote too, whoever skips it.

All coverage

What we read to write this

Discussion

Be specific. Disagree with the framing, not the person.
Commenting is part of Pro. See Pro

Loading the discussion.