Every side of every story, in your inbox by 7am.Subscribe
Theme
Appearance
Subscribe

Democrat Scott Colom defeats Sen. Cindy Hyde-Smith in Mississippi by 4,669 votes

AP called the race 8 days after Election Day. About 24% of affidavit ballots were rejected, a detail few outlets carried.

26 outlets61 headlines2 min read
Image: ABC News

The story

AP called Mississippi's Senate race for Democrat Scott Colom on Nov. 11, more than a week after Election Day. He beat Sen. Cindy Hyde-Smith by 4,669 votes, in AP's count reported by WLOX.

  • Mississippi voted on Nov. 3. Independent Ty Pinkins was also on the ballot, WLOX reported.
  • On Nov. 9, Secretary of State Michael Watson said 15,547 affidavit ballots had been processed, Newsweek reported. About 76% were accepted. Affidavit ballots are Mississippi's version of provisional ballots.
  • AP called the race at about 5 p.m. Central on Nov. 11.
  • Colom had 473,336 votes, or 49.2%. Hyde-Smith had 468,667, or 48.7%. Pinkins had 20,234, or 2.1%, WLOX reported. ABC put the margin at about 4,700.
  • Hyde-Smith conceded by phone. "I respect the decision of Mississippi voters," she said.
  • Colom said: "I had the courage to believe in Mississippi." AP reported he will be the state's first Black U.S. senator since Reconstruction.
  • Democrats will hold at least 55 Senate seats, Fox News reported, with Alaska still uncalled.
  • These results were unofficial. Counties had until Nov. 13 to certify, Newsweek reported.

How each side told it

Left-leaning outlets led with history and the map. NBC News ran: "Democrat Scott Colom wins Mississippi Senate race, breaking the GOP's grip on the state." It put the Reconstruction milestone in paragraph 2 and quoted Colom first, in paragraph 4. It gave no vote totals. ABC News led with the AP projection and gave the percentages in paragraph 2. It reached the fight over provisional ballots in paragraph 13 of 14. The Los Angeles Times headline also led with the Reconstruction milestone.

What got buried

The rejected ballots sat low on both sides. Newsweek reported that about 76% of 15,547 affidavit ballots were accepted. In Harrison County, 704 were rejected and 746 accepted, close to half. NBC, Fox News and AP did not mention rejections in the stories we read. ABC raised provisional ballots in paragraph 13 of 14. Scripps reported voters wrongly marked inactive. One voter, Thomas Minor, said he had not moved in 10 years. The state used Experian credit data to check addresses, Scripps said.

Why it matters to you

Here is the math from Newsweek's numbers. If 76% of 15,547 affidavit ballots were accepted, about 3,731 were not. That equals about 80% of the 4,669-vote margin. The reports we read do not say how those voters leaned. Scripps reported that voters without ID had until Tuesday to fix their ballot. The state posted an online tracker. If you ever cast a provisional ballot, track it and meet the fix deadline. Mississippi used credit data to flag addresses, Scripps said, so check your status before you vote.

The closer the race, the more the uncounted ballots matter.

All coverage

What we read to write this

Discussion

Be specific. Disagree with the framing, not the person.
Commenting is part of Pro. See Pro

Loading the discussion.