House blocks Massie's Hegseth impeachment push in 211-204 vote
The House sent eight impeachment articles to committee hours after Hegseth called them a stunt. Democrats take control of the House in January.

The story
The House voted 211-204 on Tuesday to send eight impeachment articles against Defense Secretary Pete Hegseth to committee. NBC News reported this effectively killed the effort in this Congress.
- Rep. Thomas Massie, a Kentucky Republican, filed eight articles of impeachment against Hegseth.
- The Daily Wire listed them. Three cover the Iran war, including breaking the War Powers Resolution. Others cover civilian deaths, boat strikes, the Maduro operation, Yemen and the treatment of Sen. Mark Kelly.
- On Tuesday, Nov. 10, Hegseth held his first Pentagon news conference in six months, AP reported.
- He called the effort "a farce" and "a stunt," NBC News reported. "This is sabotage," he said, according to AP.
- Trump posted that Hegseth "gets an 'A' PLUS, PLUS, PLUS." He called Massie a "TOTAL LOSER."
- That afternoon, the House voted 211-204 to refer the resolution to the Judiciary Committee. Massie was the only Republican to vote no, the Daily Wire reported.
- AP reported that "a number of Democrats" missed the vote. The reports we read don't say how many.
- Massie leaves Congress after losing his primary to a Trump-backed opponent, AP reported. Democrats take control of the House in January. Leader Hakeem Jeffries vowed to "run Pete Hegseth out of town."
How each side told it
Left-leaning outlets led with Hegseth's tone and the close vote. NBC News opened on a House that "narrowly rejected" the push. It quoted Massie first and put Trump's A-plus post in paragraph 15. HuffPost carried a fact others skipped: "Republicans Block Pete Hegseth Impeachment Effort With Help From Absent Democrats." NBC did not mention the absences in the version we read. The Daily Beast ran "Pentagon Pete Stages Unhinged Meltdown Over Impeachment Bid." Raw Story wrote that Hegseth "lashed out." Those words describe a mood more than a vote.










Fired by Hegseth, New Member of Congress Supports His OusterThe New York Times


Why Pete Hegseth Faces ImpeachmentThe Atlantic


‘This is sabotage’: Hegseth criticizes impeachment effort, defends Iran warThe Washington Post
What got buried
Two details sat low on both sides. The first is the empty seats. Raw Story put the House at 218 Republicans and 214 Democrats. That is 432 members, and the vote counted 415. So 17 members did not vote, and the margin was 7. AP put the missing Democrats in paragraph 14. NBC left them out. The second is a school. AP reported in paragraph 15 that cuts to a civilian-harm office came before a deadly strike on an Iranian school. Fox left the school out of the version we read.
Why it matters to you
Impeachment is the tool Congress has to check a Cabinet secretary. Tuesday's vote set its timing. For now, the articles sit with the Judiciary Committee. AP reported that Democrats take control of the House and Senate in January. Rep. Darrell Issa, a Republican, told NBC that impeachment is "going to die in the Senate." The war at the center of the articles has run 256 days, AP reported. So the War Powers question is still open. You can look up how your own House member voted on Tuesday. Check whether they voted at all.
The margin of a vote includes the people who skipped it.
All coverage
House tables Hegseth impeachment, effectively killing it in current Congress
Congress expected to vote on Hegseth impeachment Tuesday
‘We will not apologize’: Hegseth fires back at impeachment
Defiant Pete Hegseth Dismisses Impeachment Push As A 'Stunt' In First Pentagon Briefing In Months
House GOP blocks move to impeach Hegseth, handing embattled Defense secretary a win
Hegseth Lashes Out at Impeachment Push, Accuses Critics of “Sabotage”
‘It’s coming for him’: Hegseth anxiously deflecting from the hot seat as punishment inches closer
Hegseth calls impeachment articles ‘a farce’
Pete Hegseth Plays Major Victim Card in Weird Speech on Impeachment
Former Pentagon spokesman on articles of impeachment filed against Hegseth
Fired by Hegseth, New Member of Congress Supports His Ouster
Hegseth has a Senate Republican problem
‘Cowering’: GOP insider’s scathing text about Hegseth’s presser revealed on Morning Joe
Hegseth Avoided an Impeachment Vote for Now. He’s Still a Goner.
Why Pete Hegseth Faces Impeachment
Hegseth Makes Absurd Excuse After Being Cornered on Vance Election Claim
House Republicans block effort to impeach Pentagon chief Pete Hegseth
Hegseth escapes impeachment - for now
‘This is sabotage’: Hegseth criticizes impeachment effort, defends Iran war
Defense Secretary Pete Hegseth condemns impeachment effort as ‘political spectacle’
Hegseth comes out swinging against Massie impeachment push
'It's a farce': Hegseth's defiant response to impeachment effort
Does Pete Hegseth Know He’s in Politics?
Hegseth impeachment effort torpedoed in House
Hegseth Defends Himself Against Impeachment Effort: ‘It’s A Political Spectacle’
Hegseth Impeachment: Bid Stalls as House Blocks Massie's Resolution
Explainer: How would impeaching Pentagon chief Hegseth work?
‘He was very effective at killing schoolchildren’: Massie targets Hegseth in impeachment push
'A political spectacle.' Hegseth responds to articles of impeachment
Defense Secretary Hegseth Holds Rare Press Conference Over Impeachment Threat
Trump Gives Hegseth ‘A PLUS, PLUS, PLUS’ Rating for Rebuttal of Potential Impeachment
House GOP Blocks Thomas Massie’s Attempt To Impeach Pete Hegseth
Trump fawns over Pete Hegseth's 'A PLUS' blistering defense against Republican-led 'loser' impeachment effort
Daily Wire Asks Hegseth About Trump’s Backing And The New Chief In His Corner
WATCH LIVE: House votes on effort to impeach War Secretary Pete Hegseth
Democrats rally behind GOP lawmaker's Hegseth impeachment push, signal more to come in January
Massie’s Vanity Impeachment Makes Hegseth’s Exit Less Likely
Cruz: Hegseth Will Resign, Be Fired or Face Impeachment
Hegseth rips impeachment effort in first press conference since May: ‘This is not patriotism. This is sabotage’
'This is sabotage': Hegseth addresses impeachment efforts in first press conference in over 180 days
Andrew McCarthy on the Hegseth Impeachment
With Trump's backing, Hegseth vows to fight impeachment
Pete Hegseth Slams Impeachment As 'Political Spectacle' During Press Conference
Hegseth defiant in first press briefing since Thomas Massie reintroduced articles of impeachment: ‘Political spectacle’
Defense Secretary Pete Hegseth casts impeachment push as attack on U.S. troops
What we read to write this
- Associated Press House Republicans quash effort to impeach Defense Secretary Hegseth
- NBC News Republican-led House rejects Hegseth impeachment effort
- Raw Story Trump hands Hegseth a report card as his impeachment fate hangs in the balance
- Fox News House GOP leaders block Massie's Hegseth impeachment push
- The Daily Wire Massie's Hegseth Impeachment Push Crashes With Zero GOP Backup
Loading the discussion.