Schumer faces Senate leadership questions as Van Hollen weighs a challenge
Democrats could hold up to 56 Senate seats. Most reports still expect Schumer to win, and nearly all the coverage came from right-leaning outlets.

The story
Democrats could hold as many as 56 Senate seats next year, AP reported. In the headlines we track, almost every story on Chuck Schumer’s future as leader came from right-leaning outlets.
- Senators returned on Monday with leadership questions in both parties, AP reported. Both party leaders are expected to win, it said.
- The Democratic leadership vote is “likely in December,” AP said. Incoming senators get to vote before they are sworn in.
- Sen. Chris Van Hollen is reportedly considering a challenge, AP said. He said “nobody should get a blank check,” Fox News reported.
- Sen. Richard Blumenthal said “We need a conversation about leadership going forward,” Fox reported. In the same passage, he said he expects Schumer to be re-elected.
- Incoming senators Adam Hamilton and Troy Jackson won’t back Schumer, Fox said. Abdul El-Sayed backs Van Hollen, and Sherrod Brown backs Schumer, AP reported.
- Asked on the New York Times podcast “The Daily” if he expects a challenge, Schumer said “No,” Fox reported.
- Schumer also said, “If we don’t deliver, all this will go away.”
- Seat counts differed. AP said “as many as 56,” while the New York Post said “upwards of 55.”
How each side told it
In the headlines we track for Nov. 9, no left-leaning outlet ran a news story on the challenge. The Nation ran one opinion headline: “Chuck Schumer and Hakeem Jeffries Are Not Meeting the Moment.” Left reporting still shaped the story. Fox News and Newsweek both credited Politico for the report on a push to draft Van Hollen. Schumer’s “No” came from “The Daily,” a New York Times podcast. Left outlets supplied the raw material, and their own readers saw less of it that day.
What got buried
Schumer’s own support sat low. Newsweek ran about 30 paragraphs on the revolt first. It reached his structural advantages and Sen. Mark Kelly’s backing in paragraphs 31 to 34. AP named Sherrod Brown as a backer in paragraph 21. Fox News named no senator who supports him. Fox did note in paragraph 3 that he needs only a majority of the caucus. In the four reports we read, the revolt led and the backers trailed.
Why it matters to you
The Democratic leader will run a Senate that Democrats control from January. Schumer pledged to focus on affordability, AP reported in paragraph 6. The vote math is small. If the caucus has 56 members, a majority is 29 senators. Incoming senators get a vote, AP said, so the new class counts. The Mississippi and Alaska races were not called yet. Siena polling had Schumer at 32% favorable, the New York Post reported. You can read the named lists of who backs whom before trusting a headline’s word “revolt.”
The same quote can hold up two opposite headlines.
All coverage
Chuck Schumer and Hakeem Jeffries Are Not Meeting the Moment
Thune and Schumer face questions about Senate leadership in aftermath of elections
Chuck Schumer’s Future in Doubt as Momentum Grows for Chris Van Hollen
Will Sen. Van Hollen challenge Chuck Schumer for Senate Majority Leader?
Schumer's grip on power slips as Dems begin to revolt against him, eye new leadership
Chuck Schumer Faces Dem Revolt Over Senate Leadership
Democratic tsunami revives unpopular Chuck Schumer as likely next majority leader
Blumenthal declines to back Schumer as Senate majority leader
Could Democrats give Schumer the boot?
What we read to write this
- AP (via Anchorage Daily News) Thune and Schumer face questions about Senate leadership in the aftermath of midterm elections
- Fox News Schumer's grip on power slips as Dems begin to revolt against him, eye new leadership
- Newsweek Chuck Schumer's future in doubt as momentum grows for Chris Van Hollen
- New York Post (via Yahoo) Democratic tsunami revives unpopular Chuck Schumer as likely next majority leader
Loading the discussion.