Every side of every story, in your inbox by 7am.Subscribe
Theme
Appearance
Subscribe

Trump names Stephen Miller chief of staff as Susie Wiles leaves after midterm losses

Miller, 41, starts Monday, Nov. 9. Outlets split on why Wiles left, and a voter poll on immigration enforcement sat low or went missing.

44 outlets165 headlines3 min read
Image: Associated Press (via NBC4 Washington)

The story

Stephen Miller, 41, will become White House chief of staff on Monday, Nov. 9, President Trump said on Friday. The change came days after Republicans lost the House and Senate.

  • Trump announced the change on Truth Social on Friday, Nov. 6, AP and Fox News reported.
  • He called Miller one of his "most trusted advisors." Miller was deputy chief of staff for policy and also served as homeland security adviser, AP reported. He joined Trump's 2016 campaign as a speechwriter.
  • Susie Wiles, 69, was the first woman to hold the job. She served 21 months, the longest of any Trump chief of staff, Fox News reported.
  • Wiles said serving Trump "has been the honor of a lifetime." Trump said she would move to his political operation, the National News Desk reported.
  • Fox News, citing a White House official, said Wiles resigned Thursday night in a "very amicable" move. HuffPost wrote that she was "reportedly on the outs" with Trump.
  • Trump told reporters the election did not drive the change, AP reported. "I wasn't on the ballot," he said.
  • Rep. Robert Garcia, the incoming Democratic chair of House Oversight, said "Stephen Miller should lawyer up," AP reported.
  • The reports we read don't say what Wiles will do in her new role.

How each side told it

The left led with the midterm loss and with Miller's record. HuffPost's first paragraph tied the exit to a "stinging midterm election loss." It spent paragraphs 12 to 14 on Miller's record, including two U.S. citizens killed by federal agents in Minnesota. The Los Angeles Times ran: "Trump taps Stephen Miller as chief of staff, doubling down after midterm rout." CNN's headline said Trump "grows furious with midterm results." HuffPost did not carry Trump's denial that the election caused the change, in the version we read.

What got buried

One poll number sat low or went missing. In AP VoteCast, about 6 in 10 voters said immigration enforcement had "gone too far," AP reported. Immigration is the policy Miller is most tied to, AP said. In the five outlets we read, only the updated AP story carried the poll, in paragraph 17. The earlier AP version, Fox News, Fox 5 DC and HuffPost did not mention it. Fox carried its own exclusive line instead: a White House official calling the exit "very amicable."

Why it matters to you

Miller now runs the office that sits closest to the president. He also served as homeland security adviser, AP reported. In AP VoteCast, about 6 in 10 voters said enforcement had gone too far. So the White House picked the adviser most tied to the policy those voters questioned. Garcia, who will run House Oversight, has already named Miller as a target. That means you may see Miller in hearings once the new Congress sits. You can watch those yourself. One more thing to notice: headlines said "replaces," "taps" and "fires" for the same Friday. Each verb hints at a different reason, and the reports we read don't settle which one is right.

The verb in a headline is the first opinion you read.

All coverage

What we read to write this

Discussion

Be specific. Disagree with the framing, not the person.
Commenting is part of Pro. See Pro

Loading the discussion.