Every side of every story, in your inbox by 7am.Subscribe
Theme
Appearance
Subscribe

Newsom moves to commute all 548 California death sentences to life without parole

The state Supreme Court must approve 382 of them. Nine right-leaning outlets ran the story, and only two left-leaning outlets in our list did.

12 outlets14 headlines2 min read Blindspot for the left
Image: Fox News

The story

Gov. Gavin Newsom moved to commute the death sentences of 548 people in California, AP reported on Nov. 5. The state Supreme Court must approve 382 of them.

  • Newsom announced the move in an open letter on Nov. 5. He wrote that "state-sanctioned killing is incompatible with California's values," AP reported.
  • The 548 are 529 men and 19 women, AP and the Los Angeles Times reported. Each sentence would become life in prison without parole.
  • California's constitution requires the state Supreme Court to approve clemency for anyone convicted of more than one felony, AP reported. That covers 382 of the 548, about 70%.
  • The LA Times put the share needing court approval at about 60%. The two figures do not match.
  • Newsom imposed a moratorium on executions in 2019. California has not executed anyone since 2006, AP, the LA Times and Fox News reported.
  • Voters kept the death penalty in 2012 and 2016, AP reported.
  • Prosecutors pushed back. The Criminal Justice Legal Foundation filed a challenge, and Los Angeles County District Attorney Nathan Hochman backs it, NBC Los Angeles reported on Nov. 12.
  • Victims' families split. Steve Herr, whose son Sam was killed, said he was "absolutely disgusted," AP reported. Jess Nichol, sister of Polly Klaas, said execution does not help survivors heal.

How each side told it

Most left-leaning outlets in our list did not run this as news on Nov. 6. The Los Angeles Times did, at length. Its news story raised Newsom's possible presidential run in paragraph 6. Victims' families came at paragraphs 26 to 28, with relatives who oppose the death penalty quoted first. The court-approval detail came at paragraph 33. An LA Times opinion piece ran: "Newsom is right to commute death sentences. They revictimize families." Another LA Times headline called it "another big political risk."

What got buried

Precedent got almost no space. In 2018, the California Supreme Court rejected 10 clemency requests from then-Gov. Jerry Brown "with little explanation," the LA Times reported. That is a recent case of the court saying no. In the five reports we read, only the LA Times carried it, at about paragraph 34 of 39. AP, Fox News and Townhall did not mention it. Fox's "wipes out" and Townhall's "Removed" described the change as done before the court had ruled.

Why it matters to you

This is a test of what one governor can do alone. By AP's count, Newsom can act alone on 166 of the 548 cases, or about 30%. The court decides the other 382. If you live in California, voters there kept the death penalty twice, in 2012 and 2016. Hochman told NBC Los Angeles that life without parole can change later if lawmakers change parole rules. He pointed to the Menendez brothers. Newsom's term ends in January, the LA Times reported. The court's rulings before then decide how many commutations stand.

A headline can announce what a court has not decided yet.

All coverage

What we read to write this

Discussion

Be specific. Disagree with the framing, not the person.
Commenting is part of Pro. See Pro

Loading the discussion.