Every side of every story, in your inbox by 7am.Subscribe
Theme
Appearance
Subscribe

Trump makes the Oval Office a national monument, but the order allows redecorating

Trump said the rooms cannot be touched. The proclamation lets future presidents redecorate, and AP said a successor could revoke it.

19 outlets21 headlines2 min read
Image: Fox News

The story

Trump said Thursday the Oval Office "will not be allowed to be touched by anybody." His own proclamation says future presidents can still redecorate it, AP and CBS reported.

  • Trump signed the proclamation on Thursday, Nov. 5, two days after the midterms. It makes the Oval Office, the Outer Oval Office and the Cabinet Room a national monument.
  • It cites 54 U.S.C. 320301, the Antiquities Act. None of the news stories we read named that law.
  • It tells the Interior Secretary, through the National Park Service, to write a management plan. Any plan to "substantially alter or demolish" the rooms needs review first.
  • The text also states that nothing in it restricts a president's power "to redecorate the monument, select furnishings."
  • Trump said big changes would need Congress. AP and CBS said the text contains no such rule. A future president could also revoke it, AP reported.
  • Trump has added gold wall appliqués and gold-framed portraits to the Oval Office, AP said.
  • Asked if a successor could remove his gold, Trump said, "They can do anything they want, as long as they do it carefully," Reuters reported.

How each side told it

Left outlets led with timing. NBC ran: "Trump focuses on White House decor for second straight day in post-midterm remarks." Politico ran: "Trump's first post-election executive action: Preserving his Oval Office changes." NBC quoted Trump first and placed the redecorating clause in paragraph 11. Raw Story said Trump was "mocked for shielding his 'gold-plated midlife crisis'." No left story we read quoted a historian or legal expert on the order. NBC also did not name the law the proclamation relies on.

What got buried

Trump's own answer on the gold sat at the bottom of one story. Asked if a future president could remove it, he said they "can do anything they want, as long as they do it carefully." Reuters put that in paragraph 13 of 14. In the five reports we read, no other outlet carried it. It sits beside his claim that the room "won't be able to be taken down." Readers who stopped early got only the second line.

Why it matters to you

The rooms are public property, and the National Park Service now writes their management plan, the proclamation says. No report we read gave a cost for this plan or for the gold. Reuters noted that Trump cut two Utah monuments by more than 90%. That shows a later president can shrink a monument an earlier one made. To check the claims on both sides, read the proclamation itself. It is posted on whitehouse.gov.

Read the order before you read remarks about the order.

All coverage

What we read to write this

Discussion

Be specific. Disagree with the framing, not the person.
Commenting is part of Pro. See Pro

Loading the discussion.