Every side of every story, in your inbox by 7am.Subscribe
Theme
Appearance
Subscribe

California billionaire tax trails 56% to 44% as a high-earner tax passes

Opponents outraised backers about 10 to 1. Right-leaning outlets covered Prop 40 far more, and Prop 3, which passed, got little space anywhere.

14 outlets20 headlines3 min read
Image: National Review

The story

California's one-time 5% tax on billionaires trailed 56% to 44% with three-fifths of the vote counted, ABC News reported Nov. 4. AP said it was too early to call.

  • Prop 40 would tax net worth over $1 billion once, at 5%, ABC and AP reported. It covers trusts too, ABC reported. Fox Business reported it would apply to residents as of Jan. 1, 2026, paid over five years.
  • About 200 billionaires would owe it, the state voter guide said, per ABC. The Legislative Analyst's Office estimated "tens of billions" in revenue.
  • Most of the money would replace federal healthcare cuts, AP reported. Backers estimate California will lose $100 billion in federal healthcare money over five years.
  • On Wednesday morning, almost 6 million votes were still uncounted, AP reported. Yes led narrowly in Los Angeles County and on the north coast.
  • The no side raised about 10 times as much, AP reported. The committee behind rival Props 41 and 42 raised over $333 million, about 30% of it from Sergey Brin. Yes on 40 raised over $30 million, mostly from the SEIU-UHW union, ABC reported.
  • Brin and Larry Page began cutting ties with the state, AP reported. A spokesperson for Gov. Gavin Newsom called it a "poorly written state measure," ABC reported.

How each side told it

The left treated it as the night's top ballot question. ABC News ran: "Billionaire tax: What to know about California's Prop 40." It gave results in paragraph 4. Supporters' case came first, in paragraphs 12 and 13, and critics in paragraph 16. Its first quote, in paragraph 20, was Ro Khanna: "the most important ballot initiative in America." Funding came late, in paragraphs 24 and 25. It left out the Brin and Page exits. The Los Angeles Times folded it into "Multiple California ballot measures remain undecided." In the headlines we track, these were the only two left outlets on it.

What got buried

The tax that passed got almost no space. California voters approved Prop 3 the same night, a KPIX report said. It makes higher income tax rates on the top 2% of earners permanent, instead of ending in 2031. It applies above $371,000 for single filers. It raises $5 billion to $15 billion a year. ABC's Prop 40 explainer left it out. So did the Free Beacon. In the six reports we read, only the KPIX report carried it.

Why it matters to you

The money gap is the first number to check. The no side raised over $333 million, and the yes side over $30 million. That is about 11 dollars against for every 1 dollar for, close to AP's 10 to 1. Prop 3 touches more people directly. If you are single in California and earn over $371,000, your higher rate no longer ends in 2031. The billionaire tax result was not final in the reports we read. Almost 6 million votes were uncounted Wednesday morning. You can check the state's final count before treating either side's headline as settled.

Early counts describe who voted first.

All coverage

What we read to write this

Discussion

Be specific. Disagree with the framing, not the person.
Commenting is part of Pro. See Pro

Loading the discussion.