Every side of every story, in your inbox by 7am.Subscribe
Theme
Appearance
Subscribe

Supreme Court rejects Trump bid to set aside 20,000 California mail ballots

The one-line order came on the eve of the election. Right-leaning outlets covered a later appeals court win in a separate case instead.

5 outlets7 headlines2 min read
Image: BBC (via Yahoo)

The story

The Supreme Court on Nov. 2 refused to let the Justice Department hold back mail ballots from more than 20,000 California voters. Reuters said the denial came 6 hours and 24 minutes after the filing.

  • DHS built a list of about 20,000 California voters it called likely noncitizens, Reuters reported.
  • DOJ sued on Oct. 15 to make the state set those ballots aside until citizenship was checked.
  • Judge David Carter denied the request on Oct. 28. A 9th Circuit panel refused it on Oct. 30.
  • The Supreme Court's order was one sentence, Reuters said. It gave no reason and showed no public dissent.
  • California officials said the list was likely full of errors. Carter noted that people flagged as noncitizens elsewhere often turned out to be naturalized citizens.
  • Studies and state audits show noncitizen voting is rare, Reuters reported.
  • California Attorney General Rob Bonta called the federal move "desperate." A DOJ spokesperson said, "this is not the end of our efforts."
  • Unions and voting groups had brought a separate case. On Nov. 3, the full 9th Circuit voted 6-5 for the administration in it, the LA Times reported. That ruling let DOJ keep demanding set-asides and threatening election workers with prosecution.

How each side told it

The left framed the order as a rebuke. The New Republic ran: "Supreme Court Hands Trump Huge Loss in Voter Suppression Scheme." MS NOW's headline said the Court "sent Trump a midterms message." Both headlines read intent into an order that gave no reasons. The LA Times was the one left outlet we read that carried both rulings. Its headline said the "9th Circuit sides with Trump in ballot dispute." It named the Supreme Court loss in paragraph 2 and returned to it in paragraph 32.

What got buried

Most reports put low what the 9th Circuit win allowed. The LA Times said in paragraph 19 that DOJ may keep demanding set-asides and threatening prosecution. The same paragraph said the court acknowledged those threats were unlikely to hold up in court. TheBlaze said the administration was cleared "to require" set-asides. The Supreme Court denial came Monday afternoon, before the 9th Circuit's final vote. In the five reports we read, only the LA Times laid out both rulings in order.

Why it matters to you

If you voted by mail in California, the order let counting go ahead, BBC reported. BBC said the state had more than 6 million mail ballots by Sunday night. The 20,000 disputed ballots are about 0.3% of that. That is 20,000 divided by 6 million. California has about 23 million registered voters, BBC said, so the list touched under 0.1% of them. Election workers are the ones still in a bind. A 9th Circuit dissent said they face "an impossible dilemma." To get the full picture, read both rulings, since each side ran one.

Two courts ruled, and each side reported one.

All coverage

What we read to write this

Discussion

Be specific. Disagree with the framing, not the person.
Commenting is part of Pro. See Pro

Loading the discussion.