Every side of every story, in your inbox by 7am.Subscribe
Theme
Appearance
Subscribe

Supreme Court rejects DOJ bid to set aside 20,000 California mail ballots

The one-sentence order came the day before the midterms. Lower courts, a UCLA study and a DOJ lawyer had raised doubts about the list behind it.

28 outlets43 headlines2 min read
Image: Associated Press (via NBC Los Angeles)

The story

The Supreme Court used one sentence on Monday to reject a Justice Department request about 20,000 California ballots. The state has about 23 million registered voters, AP reported, so the list covered under 0.1% of them.

  • The Justice Department sued California on Oct. 15, Fox News reported. It said it had found 20,000 likely noncitizens on the state's voter roll.
  • DHS first told California that 190,832 noncitizens might be registered, Townhall reported. The list later shrank to about 20,000.
  • Judge Carter, a federal trial judge, refused to step in. He warned the demand would "wreak havoc" on the midterms, AP reported.
  • On Friday, Oct. 30, the 9th Circuit ruled 2-1 against the department, NPR reported. Judge Bumatay, a Trump appointee, dissented.
  • Solicitor General Sauer filed with the Supreme Court on Monday morning. The court denied the request hours later, with no reasoning and no public dissent.
  • In court, DOJ lawyer Kenneth Kao was asked whether the error rate was high. He said, "That's a fair statement," AP reported.
  • Bill Essayli, who runs the federal prosecutors' office in Los Angeles, said 34 people on the list had been charged with election-related crimes, the Daily Wire reported.
  • The reports we read do not explain how the 20,000 names were picked.

How each side told it

The left led with the rejection and the doubts. NPR ran: "The Supreme Court rejects a DOJ push to separate California ballots." It quoted Judge Carter first, on a "pattern of attempted election interference." NPR put "likely" in quotation marks and said the true number is likely "much smaller." It gave the UCLA data in paragraph 11. NBC News ran: "Supreme Court quickly rejects Trump effort to target alleged noncitizen voters." The NPR story quoted no Justice Department official directly.

What got buried

The best test of the list sat low. The UCLA Voting Rights Project found 42% of the names are not on the current voter file, NPR reported. It said the list includes naturalized citizens. In the six reports we read, only NPR carried it, in paragraph 11. AP carried Kao's "fair statement" answer around paragraph 12. None of the three right-leaning stories we read included either detail.

Why it matters to you

Here is the math on the UCLA figure. 42% of 20,000 names is about 8,400 people who are not on the current voter file. County officials also found many people on the list were never mailed a ballot, NPR reported, without giving a count. The other side has a number too. Essayli said 34 people on the list were charged. More than 6 million California ballots were already returned when the court ruled, AP reported. The order leaves the lower-court blocks in place. Read how a list was built before you trust its total.

A number is only as good as the list behind it.

All coverage

What we read to write this

Discussion

Be specific. Disagree with the framing, not the person.
Commenting is part of Pro. See Pro

Loading the discussion.