Every side of every story, in your inbox by 7am.Subscribe
Theme
Appearance
Subscribe

Judge tosses case against two ex-FBI officials in Hunter Biden probe dispute

A magistrate judge found no probable cause and called the case rushed and political. The Justice Department said it is weighing its options.

12 outlets12 headlines2 min read
Image: NBC News (via NBC New York)

The story

A federal judge threw out charges against two former FBI officials on Monday. Prosecutors charged them about two weeks before the midterms, three years after the 2023 testimony at issue.

  • The officials are Nikki Floris and Bradley Benavides. Prosecutors said they misled Congress in 2023 about their roles in the Hunter Biden investigations, AP and NBC reported.
  • Prosecutors said their statements were contradicted by internal FBI messages and witness accounts, Fox News reported.
  • The probe opened a day after a July speech by President Trump. FBI Director Kash Patel mandated it, AP reported.
  • Prosecutors charged the pair by criminal complaint. AP and NPR reported that this tool is meant for urgent cases.
  • On Monday, Nov. 2, U.S. Magistrate Judge Zia Faruqui ruled from the bench in Washington. He found no probable cause, ABC News reported. He said he had never before found the government failed that standard.
  • He said, "What has transpired here cannot be described as anything other than weaponization." On the timing, he said he would not "pretend that I cannot read a calendar," AP reported.
  • The Justice Department disagreed. It said it is "evaluating all options," ABC and NPR reported.
  • Prosecutors can still ask a grand jury to indict. NBC called that unlikely.

How each side told it

The left led with the judge's word. ABC News ran: "'Weaponization': Judge blasts DOJ in dismissing case against ex-FBI agents." It quoted the judge first. It named Patel, Attorney General Todd Blanche and U.S. Attorney Jeanine Pirro as targets of his criticism. The department's reply came near the end. NBC News led with the missing probable cause. It quoted the defense first: "Bradley Benavides is a patriot." NBC described the accusations in paragraph 6.

What got buried

The origin of the case sat at the bottom. The Justice Department's case cited a 2020 briefing the officials gave Sens. Chuck Grassley and Ron Johnson, AP reported. The senators say it was used to tie their probe to Russian disinformation. In the five reports we read, only AP carried it, in its last paragraph. ABC, NBC, Fox and NPR left it out. NBC alone carried another detail: the case agent testified that a top Pirro aide called the complaint flawed.

Why it matters to you

Two rules shaped this ruling. A complaint is meant for urgent cases, AP and NPR reported. The judge saw no urgency, and he suggested prosecutors were avoiding a D.C. grand jury, NPR reported. The Justice Department also has a 60-day rule on overt steps in politically sensitive cases before an election, ABC reported. Two weeks is about 46 days short of 60. The judge warned the case could deter people from joining the FBI, ABC said. The case may still return through a grand jury, so the next filing is the one to read.

A charge's timing is part of its record.

All coverage

What we read to write this

Discussion

Be specific. Disagree with the framing, not the person.
Commenting is part of Pro. See Pro

Loading the discussion.