Trump says US and Canada have 'the concept of a very good deal' on trade
Carney reported progress after a Saturday call, and Trump said Canada would build and pay for the Keystone XL pipeline. No terms were set.

The story
In August, Trump put 50% tariffs on roughly $20 billion in Canadian goods, AP reported. On Nov. 1 he said, "We have the concept of a very good deal with Canada."
- US-Canada talks collapsed in August, AP reported. Canada walked away over demands that Prime Minister Mark Carney said threatened its sovereignty, French-language protections and auto industry.
- Trump then put 50% tariffs on roughly $20 billion in Canadian goods, and Canada hit back, AP reported.
- On Oct. 28, Carney said Canada was "not yet in a position to reach an agreement" before the midterms, AP reported.
- Trump and Carney spoke by phone on Saturday, Oct. 31. On Nov. 1, Carney posted that "Our teams will now be working in the coming weeks" on a deal.
- Trump spoke to reporters after landing in Iowa. He said Canada would build the Keystone XL pipeline and pay for "all of it," Reuters and The Canadian Press reported. He said farmers "will have to pay no tariffs," AP reported.
- AP said talks cover possible relief from US tariffs on Canadian steel and cars. No details were announced, and final terms were not set, AP reported.
- The reports we read don't give a total figure for US-Canada trade.
How each side told it
Left outlets mostly ran the wire version. The Washington Post carried AP's story, which led with Carney's account and quoted him first. It reached Keystone in paragraph 8 and the tariff size in paragraph 10. CNN's headline used a plural: "Trump says he has 'concepts of a very good deal' with Canada." AP, Reuters and The Canadian Press all quoted the singular "concept." Politico led with Carney, saying teams "will work on trade deal in 'coming weeks'." We could not open the CNN or Politico pages.
What got buried
Whether Keystone XL can be built sat low. Reuters noted that President Biden revoked its key permit in 2021. In paragraph 8, it reported that South Bow, spun off from TC Energy, has proposed a smaller line. That line, Prairie Connector, would carry 550,000 barrels a day to Wyoming, with a decision due in 2027. Keystone XL was planned for 830,000 barrels a day to Cushing, Oklahoma, Reuters said. AP and The Canadian Press did not mention South Bow.
Why it matters to you
The tariffs are the part you may feel in prices. Fifty percent on $20 billion of goods is $10 billion, on paper. The reports we read don't say over what period that $20 billion is counted. Canada sends more than 90% of its crude oil to the US, Reuters reported. Trump said farmers would pay no tariffs under a deal. AP said final details were not set. In the reports we read, no tariff has been lifted yet. The next fact to look for is the written text Carney said teams would work on "in the coming weeks."
A concept is a promise to write the terms later.
All coverage
Trump says he has ‘concepts of a very good deal’ with Canada
Mark Carney says US, Canada teams will work on trade deal in ‘coming weeks’
Canada's Carney reports progress in trade talks with US. Trump talks up 'concept' of a deal
Canada’s Carney reports progress in trade talks with US. Trump talks up ‘concept’ of a deal
Trump floats 'concept' of US-Canada deal that includes pipeline talking to Carney
Trump, Carney Signal Progress on Canada Trade Deal
Canadian Prime Minister Carney reports progress in trade talks with Trump days before U.S. midterms
What we read to write this
- Associated Press (via Anchorage Daily News) Canada's Carney reports progress in trade talks with US. Trump talks up 'concept' of a deal
- Associated Press (via PBS) Canada's Carney reports progress in trade talks with U.S. and Trump talks up 'concept' of a deal
- Reuters (via News Tribune) Trump floats 'concept' of US-Canada deal that includes pipeline talking to Carney
- Reuters (via Devdiscourse) Trump floats 'concept' of US-Canada deal that includes pipeline talking to Carney
- The Canadian Press (via TruckNews) Trump says US, Canada have the 'concept of a very good deal'
Loading the discussion.