Every side of every story, in your inbox by 7am.Subscribe
Theme
Appearance
Subscribe

Judge orders Justice Department to stop threatening election officials

The order came days before the midterms. A court filing the same weekend said 42% of names on a DOJ noncitizen list were not California voters.

14 outlets19 headlines2 min read
Image: Fox News

The story

A federal judge ordered the Justice Department on Oct. 30 to stop threatening election officials with prosecution. The next day, an analysis reported by AP said 42% of names on a DOJ noncitizen list were not California voters.

  • In July, Civil Rights Division head Harmeet Dhillon warned all 50 states and D.C. of prosecution if officials knowingly let noncitizens vote, CBS reported.
  • On Oct. 13, the department asked California to set aside about 20,000 ballots it believed noncitizens cast, Newsweek reported. The state refused.
  • On Oct. 28, Judge David O. Carter refused to make the state set those ballots aside, CBS reported. An appeals court denied the department's request on Oct. 30, Fox News reported.
  • Groups including SEIU and the NAACP sued on Oct. 29, Fox reported. On the night of Oct. 30, U.S. District Judge Trina Thompson issued an 8-page temporary order. She found the government likely violated the Voting Rights Act's ban on intimidation.
  • The order expires Nov. 16, CBS reported. CNN said it covers officials across the country, while CBS put California in its headline.
  • Department spokesperson Kiersten Pels called it a "two-track system of justice," Newsweek reported. The department appealed on Saturday, AP reported.
  • A Saturday court filing by groups suing the department covered 20,930 names, AP reported. Of those, 8,880 did not match California's voter file. The department disputes it.

How each side told it

The left led with the judge's words. CBS put "intimidate" and "threaten" in its headline and quoted Thompson first. NBC called it a "broad order" and quoted her line about "a campaign to intimidate, threaten, and coerce." The NBC version we read had no response from the department. The Daily Beast went furthest: "Judge Humiliates Rabid Trump Goons." Neither CBS nor NBC said which president appointed Thompson. CBS gave the department's statement in paragraph 10 of 11.

What got buried

Two details sat low. Fox put the appeals court's denial on the 20,000 ballots in paragraph 12, its last. CBS did not name that court. The human cost sat lower still. ABC reported in paragraph 6 that San Benito County registrar Francisco Diaz planned how to run his office if he were arrested. In paragraph 16, ABC said 4 poll workers there did not show up. In the reports we read, only ABC carried either detail.

Why it matters to you

If you vote in California, the list behind this fight is the number to know. The filing said 8,880 of 20,930 names, or 42%, did not match any registered voter, AP reported. It said at least 22 were U.S. citizens. It also said about 7,500 naturalized citizens were likely flagged by mistake. The department disputes the analysis, and the reports we read show no neutral check of it. The department wanted about 20,000 ballots set aside. Two federal judges and an appeals court said no before Election Day. If you were told your ballot is in question, call your county registrar.

A list is only as good as how it was matched.

All coverage

What we read to write this

Discussion

Be specific. Disagree with the framing, not the person.
Commenting is part of Pro. See Pro

Loading the discussion.