Every side of every story, in your inbox by 7am.Subscribe
Theme
Appearance
Subscribe

DOJ asks to set aside Alaska ballots that rank the second Dan Sullivan

Federal prosecutors confirmed a criminal probe and asked a court to separate ballots. Mary Peltola said she knew nothing about the second candidate.

32 outlets97 headlines3 min read
Image: ABC News

The story

Federal prosecutors asked a judge on Oct. 30 to set aside every Alaska ballot that ranks Dan J. Sullivan. Election Day was four days away, and no one had been charged.

  • The New York Times reported on Oct. 28 that Peltola staff, lawyers and Democratic Senate committee aides helped push Dan J. Sullivan to run. ABC summarized the report.
  • He shares a name with Sen. Dan S. Sullivan, the Republican incumbent. Mary Peltola, a Democrat, is challenging the senator.
  • That night, Gov. Mike Dunleavy ordered state police to look at whether the effort broke Alaska law, CBS reported.
  • On Oct. 29, Peltola told a Juneau rally: "I knew nothing about any other candidates on the ballot."
  • On Oct. 30, U.S. Attorney Michael Heyman confirmed a criminal probe. He named no crime and no target, the AP reported. "I'm not making any assumptions on whether a crime has been committed," he said, per Alaska Public Media.
  • The same day, the Justice Department asked a court to "preserve and segregate all ballots ranking Daniel J. Sullivan." Alaska's Department of Law said this would break ballot secrecy, CBS reported.
  • Peltola's former campaign manager told the Times that Peltola was "definitely aware." ABC reported she later asked the Times to retract her statements.
  • The reports we read don't say which law, if any, was broken.

How each side told it

The left led with the investigations and Peltola's denial. NBC News ran: "DOJ issues subpoenas in Alaska Senate race as governor launches separate investigation." CBS News built a headline on Peltola's own words, that she "knew nothing about" the other Dan Sullivan. NBC's ballot story said in paragraph 3 that the DOJ filing did not explain how its review would work. CBS quoted Gov. Dunleavy first and put the Democrats' reply at the end. The Guardian's headline called it an "alleged Democratic plot." So the left told a story about prosecutors and timing.

What got buried

Two details sat low on both sides. The first is legality. The Times itself called such tactics "generally considered legal," used by both parties in Alaska. In the reports we read, only Alaska Public Media quoted that line, mid-to-late in its story. The second is the prosecutor. Heyman had been recused while he was considered for a judgeship. CBS put this in its final paragraph, 23 of 23. Daily Wire ran it last too. Both sides put the question of whether any crime fits the facts below the accusations.

Why it matters to you

This race helps decide the Senate. Republicans hold 53 seats to 47, and Democrats need four more, Newsweek reported. In the August primary, Dan J. Sullivan won 2%, ABC reported. Peltola won 48% and Sen. Sullivan 43%. Newsweek listed recent polls with Peltola ahead by 2, 2 and 7 points. So the second Sullivan's primary share equals the gap in two of those three polls. DOJ's earlier civil suit asks the court to block certification if Sen. Sullivan loses over "voter confusion," CBS reported. If you vote in Alaska, the ballot lists party and incumbency beside each name, ABC noted.

A probe is a question, and a charge is an answer.

All coverage

What we read to write this

Discussion

Be specific. Disagree with the framing, not the person.
Commenting is part of Pro. See Pro

Loading the discussion.