Every side of every story, in your inbox by 7am.Subscribe
Theme
Appearance
Subscribe

Appeals court rejects DOJ bid to set aside 20,000 California ballots, 2-1

A 9th Circuit panel said the plan risked disenfranchising eligible voters. The dissent said the court should have let the Justice Department try.

20 outlets23 headlines2 min read
Image: Democracy Docket

The story

A federal appeals court voted 2-1 on Oct. 30 against setting aside about 20,000 California ballots. California has more than 23 million registered voters, Democracy Docket reported.

  • On Oct. 13, the Justice Department asked California to set aside ballots of about 20,000 voters it called "likely noncitizens," Newsweek reported. DOJ sued on Oct. 15.
  • On Oct. 26, a 9th Circuit panel dismissed a first appeal. It said DOJ gave the lower court a "mere 15 hours."
  • On Oct. 28, Judge David Carter denied DOJ's request, saying it would "wreak havoc" on the election, Reuters reported.
  • On Oct. 30, the same panel denied DOJ again, 2-1. Judge Mark Bennett, a Trump appointee, and Judge Gabriel Sanchez, a Biden appointee, formed the majority. Trump appointee Patrick Bumatay dissented.
  • The majority said the list "may not be fully reliable," Reuters reported. It said there is "no feasible way" to pull out specific ballots, the AP reported.
  • Bumatay wrote: "We should have let them try."
  • DOJ "has not said how many of these people have submitted ballots," Reuters reported.

How each side told it

The left led with DOJ losing. The Los Angeles Times ran: "9th Circuit again denies Trump administration request to block 20,000 California ballots." Raw Story ran: "Trump-appointed judge casts deciding vote against DOJ's 'catastrophic' ballot scheme." In the version we read, Raw Story's body never named Bennett or gave the vote count. It put "likely noncitizens" in scare quotes and called the plan a "scheme." It did quote Bumatay's dissent, in paragraph 5. The New York Times chose the word "Impound" for its headline, a word the court did not use in the reports we read.

What got buried

How the list was built got almost no space on either side. DOJ said DHS produced it. Raw Story said, in paragraph 4, that Judge Carter found DOJ gave no error rates for how "a data vendor matched names." UCLA researchers, in a filing for an immigrant rights group, said 8,880 names (42%) did not match the state voter file. DOJ disputes that work. The AP put another detail in paragraphs 20 to 22: Los Angeles County officials received grand jury subpoenas.

Why it matters to you

If you vote by mail in California, your ballot is mixed with others once it is processed. Hundreds of thousands had been processed, the AP reported. Officials said those ballots "can't be matched back" to the voters who sent them. The math: 20,000 names out of more than 23 million registered voters is under 0.1%. If the UCLA count holds, 42% of those names did not match the voter file. DOJ said "every ballot cast by an ineligible voter cancels out the vote of an American citizen." Ask any report on this case for the list's error rate. The ones we read had none.

A list is only as good as its error rate.

All coverage

What we read to write this

Discussion

Be specific. Disagree with the framing, not the person.
Commenting is part of Pro. See Pro

Loading the discussion.