Every side of every story, in your inbox by 7am.Subscribe
Theme
Appearance
Subscribe

New York Times reports Ilhan Omar probe includes scrutiny of her 2009 marriage

Unnamed officials said a 2016 inquiry found some evidence of fraud. Omar calls it a debunked conspiracy theory. Right-leaning outlets carried most of the coverage.

13 outlets18 headlines2 min read Blindspot for the left
Image: TMZ

The story

Of 13 outlets on our list with an Ilhan Omar headline on Oct. 29, 10 lean right. The story came from The New York Times, which reported a federal probe is examining her 2009 marriage.

  • A federal investigation of Rep. Ilhan Omar is partly examining her 2009 marriage to Ahmed Nur Said Elmi, The New York Times reported on Oct. 29.
  • It asks whether the marriage was a sham to get a suspected brother a green card, the Times said.
  • In summer 2016, the FBI and Homeland Security found "some evidence" of fraud, per six officials on that probe. The case stalled on the five-year time limit for charges.
  • The Times said it is unclear what evidence shows Elmi was her brother. It is also unclear if any charge could avoid the time limit.
  • Agents searched her Washington home on Oct. 12, the Times reported. Democrats said the search broke the Justice Department's pre-election policy.
  • The probe also reviews her late father's immigration forms, the Times said.
  • Omar's spokesperson said she "repeatedly and unequivocally denied this baseless, disgusting conspiracy theory."
  • About 175 House Democrats signed a letter led by Rep. Pramila Jayapal asking the administration to stop the probe, Fox News reported. Nancy Pelosi and Steny Hoyer did not sign.
  • No charge has been filed. All the officials quoted are unnamed.

How each side told it

Few left outlets covered it that day. The New York Times broke it under a measured headline: "Investigation Involves New Scrutiny of Long-Disputed Marriage." It gave Omar's denial in paragraph 3 and her spokesperson's quote in paragraph 14. It put its own caveat in paragraph 7: the brother evidence is unclear. NBC ran: "Ilhan Omar faces scrutiny over immigration allegations." CNN, MS NOW and The Washington Post, all on our list, had no Omar headline that day.

What got buried

The Times' own caveats sat low. In paragraph 7 of 42, it said it is unclear what evidence shows Elmi was her brother. In paragraph 8, it said it is unclear whether any charge is still possible. The Daily Wire cited the Times for its headline and left out both lines. The Times also reported, in paragraphs 23 to 25, a 2016 letter from US Attorney Andrew Luger saying "not investigating." Luger now says the letter was never meant to address the substance.

Why it matters to you

This story shows how one report travels. Ten right-leaning outlets on our list ran it that day. Two left-leaning ones did, counting the Times itself. Each side leaned on different paragraphs. Paragraph 2 says officials found "some evidence." Paragraph 7 says the brother evidence is unclear. Both lines come from the same report. If you read one side's version, you likely got one of them. A home search, a letter from about 175 lawmakers and no charge are all on the record. You can read the original before the retelling.

The source you quote is also the source you skip.

All coverage

What we read to write this

Discussion

Be specific. Disagree with the framing, not the person.
Commenting is part of Pro. See Pro

Loading the discussion.