Every side of every story, in your inbox by 7am.Subscribe
Theme
Appearance
Subscribe

Alaska and the Justice Department open probes over a second Dan Sullivan on the ballot

A New York Times report said Peltola campaign staff discussed recruiting a same-name candidate. Peltola denied it. No one has been charged.

34 outlets95 headlines3 min read
Image: NBC Washington (AP)

The story

The Justice Department sent at least three dozen subpoenas and records requests in Alaska's Senate race on Oct. 29, AP reported. Experts AP quoted said the alleged tactic is not illegal, and could not name a federal law it breaks.

  • Republican Sen. Dan S. Sullivan faces Democrat Mary Peltola on a ranked-choice ballot. Dan J. Sullivan, a retired Petersburg schoolteacher, is also on it, AP reported.
  • A state elections official first ruled him ineligible, saying he filed "with a purpose to confuse or mislead." The Alaska Supreme Court later ruled he qualified.
  • The New York Times then reported texts among Peltola campaign members about recruiting people with the senator's name, AP said. The Times said Democratic Senatorial Campaign Committee staff were on the texts.
  • On Oct. 28, Trump said, "I think they should be prosecuted."
  • On Oct. 29, the Justice Department issued new grand jury subpoenas. Its court filing said the Times report contradicts Democratic lawyers who told the court they "lack knowledge" of how he entered the race.
  • Gov. Mike Dunleavy, a Republican, told the state Department of Public Safety to decide "whether criminal charges or civil action are warranted." House Oversight Chairman James Comer asked to interview former campaign manager Elisa Rios and operative Jerid Kurtz.
  • Peltola said, "I knew nothing about any other candidate." Her campaign and the Senate committee denied involvement, AP reported.
  • No one has been charged. The targets of the federal probe are unclear, AP said.

How each side told it

Left outlets split between alarm and dismissal. CNN's analysis ran: "Alaska Democrats just handed Trump a political gift." MS NOW wrote that Republicans "pick a fight over campaign mischief they can't win." HuffPost's headline called the controversy "A Nonissue." The AP version NBC carried put the legal view in paragraph 1: experts said the tactic "isn't illegal." It quoted Justin Levitt, a former Biden-era Justice official, in paragraph 7. He said "the point of the investigation is to become the story." Peltola's denial came in paragraph 21.

What got buried

The Times' main named source tried to take back her words. AP reported in paragraph 18 of 19 that fired campaign manager Elisa Rios tried to retract her comments. The Daily Wire carried it higher, in paragraph 5. It added that the Times says the texts back up her account. The law sat low too. AP put experts saying no federal law clearly applies in paragraphs 15 and 16 of 19. Notre Dame law professor Derek Muller called it "a dirty campaign trick" for voters to judge.

Why it matters to you

If you vote in Alaska, your ballot lists four Senate candidates, and two share a name. The Justice Department has sued to block certification if Peltola wins, AP reported. State lawyers warned the suit could "cast a cloud over Alaska's election." They asked the court to rule by Monday, Nov. 2. Election Day is Nov. 3. So a court ruling may land one day before you vote, and more fights may follow the count. Each name on a ranked-choice ballot can matter. You can check the full name and party before you mark each choice.

An investigation is a question, and a charge is an answer.

All coverage

What we read to write this

Discussion

Be specific. Disagree with the framing, not the person.
Commenting is part of Pro. See Pro

Loading the discussion.