Every side of every story, in your inbox by 7am.Subscribe
Theme
Appearance
Subscribe

Report says Peltola allies recruited a second Dan Sullivan, Trump calls for prosecution

A New York Times report leaned partly on a fired campaign manager who later tried to retract. Peltola called it "another distraction."

35 outlets66 headlines3 min read
Image: Fox News

The story

A New York Times report said Mary Peltola's campaign helped put a second Dan Sullivan on Alaska's Senate ballot. Within a day, President Trump said "they should be prosecuted," AP reported.

  • The Times reported on Oct. 28 that Peltola's campaign and Senate Democratic aides worked to recruit spoiler candidates. ABC News said the Times cited "12 sources, text messages and documents."
  • The other candidate is Dan J. Sullivan, a retired schoolteacher from Petersburg, AP reported. He faces Republican Sen. Dan Sullivan on the Nov. 3 ranked-choice ballot.
  • Dan J. Sullivan told AP he had "Zero, none, zilch" contact with Peltola's campaign.
  • Peltola called the report "another diversion," AP reported. The Democratic Senatorial Campaign Committee said it is "not involved with Dan J. Sullivan."
  • Trump posted that Peltola "should suffer the Legal and Political consequences." Sen. Lisa Murkowski said Alaskans "deserve the honest truth" from Peltola's campaign, AP reported.
  • ABC said the Justice Department has an active criminal investigation into the second Sullivan's candidacy.
  • Ballot-stacking is common and widely considered legal, ABC reported. Alaska courts found nothing illegal about his candidacy.
  • One honest limit: the Times relied partly on Elisa Rios, Peltola's former campaign manager, AP said. She was fired in August and later tried to take back her comments.

How each side told it

Left-leaning outlets led with the report and Peltola's denial. ABC News ran: "Peltola campaign under fire after report that it recruited second Dan Sullivan." Its first quote, in paragraph 4, was a Peltola spokesperson denying any role. Trump came in paragraph 9. ABC put the line that ballot-stacking is widely considered legal in paragraph 13. CBS News pinned its headline to the Times: "Democrats pushed to get second Dan Sullivan on Alaska ballot." HuffPost led with Trump's response: "Trump Demands Mary Peltola Be Taken Off Alaska Senate Race Ballot."

What got buried

Two details sat low on both sides. The first is the law. AP quoted Notre Dame law professor Derek Muller in paragraph 19: "It's a dirty campaign trick." He added that it is now "in the hands of the voters." Fox News carried no legal expert in the version we read. The second is the source. AP put the fired manager's attempt to retract in paragraph 21, its last. ABC put it in paragraph 15. The claim about Peltola herself rests on Rios. In the three reports we read, no outlet confirmed it independently.

Why it matters to you

If you vote in Alaska, two people named Dan Sullivan are on your ballot. More than 61,000 ballots had been cast through Tuesday, Oct. 27, AP reported. Some of those voters marked a ballot before this report came out. Legal experts told AP the report likely won't change the Justice Department's lawsuit over certifying the result. The DSCC said Republicans have "a long history" of propping up candidates, ABC reported. Each party now accuses the other of the same move. Courts look unlikely to settle this before Election Day. Check the full name on every line before you mark your ballot.

A story built on one source is only as strong as that source.

All coverage

What we read to write this

Discussion

Be specific. Disagree with the framing, not the person.
Commenting is part of Pro. See Pro

Loading the discussion.