Every side of every story, in your inbox by 7am.Subscribe
Theme
Appearance
Subscribe

Judge rejects DOJ bid to set aside 20,000 California ballots of alleged noncitizens

Judge David O. Carter said the move would "wreak havoc" on an election already underway. The Justice Department said it will appeal.

14 outlets16 headlines2 min read Blindspot for the right
Image: Associated Press (via News4JAX)

The story

A federal judge refused on Oct. 28 to make California set aside up to 20,000 mail ballots, AP reported. In a sample of 200 names on the list, more than half were canceled or inactive registrations, CBS News reported.

  • The Justice Department sued California and Los Angeles County in mid-October. It wanted ballots from people on its list of alleged noncitizens kept apart.
  • U.S. District Judge David O. Carter denied the emergency request on Wednesday, Oct. 28.
  • He wrote that it "would wreak havoc and disrupt the election that is already underway," AP reported. CBS News said he called the method behind the list "vague."
  • Bill Essayli, the First Assistant U.S. Attorney, said segregating a ballot "does not prevent it from being counted later," AP reported.
  • Los Angeles County sampled 200 records on the list. Just over 38% said they were born in the US, CBS reported. A USCIS official disputed this and said none were.
  • More than 3.7 million Californians had voted, AP said. The Justice Department said it will appeal.
  • No report we read says how many people on the list are noncitizens.

How each side told it

Left-leaning outlets led with the judge's rebuke. The Los Angeles Times called it a "blistering opinion" in its headline. CBS News ran: "Judge rejects Trump administration's push to force California to set aside" thousands of ballots. CBS quoted Carter first, in paragraph 4: "Never before in American history." It gave the most space to problems with the list, including the 200-record sample. CBS put the judge's party label, a Clinton appointee, in paragraph 18. It said noncitizen voting is rare in paragraph 36, near the end.

What got buried

The list's error rate sat low everywhere. Breitbart reported in paragraph 9 that the Justice Department disclosed no error rate. That same paragraph said the list began at 190,832 names. CBS put the Los Angeles sample in paragraph 32. AP did not include it in the version we read. So the 20,000 figure in many headlines is the government's count. No report we read gave an independent check of it. AP said 28 noncitizens had been arrested. Breitbart said 28 were charged and 11 arrested.

Why it matters to you

If you vote by mail in California, the judge refused to pull your ballot aside for this list. About 23 million voters are mailed ballots, AP reported. The list covered up to 20,000 people. That is under 0.1% of mailed voters. Carter said the right tool is charging individual voters later, CBS reported. Federal law already makes noncitizen voting a crime, Breitbart noted. Washington state faces a similar request covering more than 400 ballots, CBS said. The case is still open. The Justice Department said it would appeal.

A list's size means little until someone checks its errors.

All coverage

What we read to write this

Discussion

Be specific. Disagree with the framing, not the person.
Commenting is part of Pro. See Pro

Loading the discussion.