Grand jury declines to indict former White House aide Cassidy Hutchinson
Prosecutors sought charges over her Jan. 6 testimony. Left-leaning outlets covered the refusal widely, and one right-leaning outlet in our list did.

The story
A Washington grand jury refused to indict Cassidy Hutchinson on Oct. 27, AP reported. In 2016, federal grand juries declined about 0.004% of cases, Reason wrote, citing the Bureau of Justice Statistics.
- Hutchinson was a White House aide and a witness in the House Jan. 6 inquiry. Republican lawmakers accused her of lying under oath in 2022 testimony, AP reported.
- In March, Reps. Barry Loudermilk and Jim Jordan asked the Justice Department to prosecute her, Reason wrote.
- On Tuesday, Oct. 27, the grand jury returned a "no bill," a formal refusal to charge, NBC News reported.
- NBC said the case came from the Civil Rights Division, led by Trump appointee Harmeet Dhillon.
- The exact charges were not clear, AP reported. Reason wrote they were most likely false statements and perjury, each with a five-year maximum.
- Hutchinson declined to comment through her lawyer, AP said. NBC said the Justice Department did not immediately respond.
- Prosecutors can still try again, NBC reported.
- AP placed the case among other pre-midterm moves, including a renewed case against James Comey.
How each side told it
Left-leaning outlets led with Hutchinson's role as a witness against Trump. NBC News named Dhillon's division in paragraph 7. It carried Trump's past insults and a list of other Trump foes, from Adam Schiff to Letitia James. NBC put the Secret Service dispute of her account in paragraph 15. MS NOW went further in its headline: "When weaponized justice flops." The Washington Post grouped her with others: "Comey, Hutchinson and more Trump foes are in Justice Dept.'s pre-election sights."
What got buried
The rarity of a refusal sat in one place. Reason cited federal data: grand juries declined about 0.004% of cases in 2016. AP called the refusal "highly unusual" but gave no figure. NBC carried a related detail low in its story. The chief federal judge in Washington now requires prosecutors to tell the on-duty magistrate when a grand jury refuses an indictment. The right mostly left the story out. Of the 12 headlines on it in our list, one came from a right-leaning outlet.
Why it matters to you
A grand jury is made up of ordinary residents, and these reports show it can say no to prosecutors. At 0.004%, that is about 4 refusals in every 100,000 cases. That math uses the 2016 rate Reason cited. NBC reported the Justice Department tried three more times to indict Letitia James after her first case was dismissed. Grand juries rejected all three. If you are ever called for grand jury duty, your vote counts as a check on charges. The reports we read don't say whether prosecutors will try Hutchinson again.
A rare outcome deserves its base rate beside it.
All coverage
Video Grand jury refuses to indict former White House staffer Cassidy Hutchinson
Grand jury refuses to indict former White House aide Cassidy Hutchinson
When weaponized justice flops: Cassidy Hutchinson case turns humiliating for Trump’s DOJ
DOJ’s ‘shocking’ flurry of pre-election activity breaks long-standing precedent, former officials say
Here Are the U.S. Attorneys Who Are Carrying Out Trump’s Grievance Agenda
Comey, Hutchinson and more Trump foes are in Justice Dept.’s pre-election sights
Israelis await final election results, grand jury refuses to indict former White House aide
Grand jury declines to indict former White House aide Cassidy Hutchinson, source says
The Memo: DOJ targets Trump foes in flurry of activity in election’s shadow
Justice Department Push Against Trump’s Foes Reaches Higher Gear
The failed indictment of Cassidy Hutchinson reflects grand jury resistance to politically motivated charges
What we read to write this
- Associated Press (via AJC) Grand jury refuses to indict former White House aide Cassidy Hutchinson, AP sources say
- Associated Press (via PBS NewsHour) Grand jury refuses to indict former White House aide Cassidy Hutchinson, AP sources say
- NBC News (via NBC Boston) Grand jury declines to indict Cassidy Hutchinson over Jan. 6 testimony
- Reason The Failed Indictment of Cassidy Hutchinson Reflects Grand Jury Resistance to Politically Motivated Charges
Loading the discussion.