Every side of every story, in your inbox by 7am.Subscribe
Theme
Appearance
Subscribe

Judge rules DOJ unlawfully fired prosecutor Maurene Comey and orders back pay

Judge Jesse Furman said the firing broke civil service law and her due-process rights. The Justice Department said it will appeal.

16 outlets16 headlines3 min read
Image: NBC News

The story

A federal judge ruled on Monday, Oct. 26, that the Justice Department broke the law when it fired prosecutor Maurene Comey in July 2025. His 55-page decision orders retroactive reinstatement and back pay, CBS and CNBC reported.

  • Comey became a federal prosecutor in Manhattan in 2015, CBS reported. She worked on cases against Sean Combs, Jeffrey Epstein and Ghislaine Maxwell. She is the daughter of former FBI director James Comey.
  • She was fired on July 16, 2025. The DOJ later said then-Attorney General Pam Bondi directed the firing, CBS reported.
  • She sued in September 2025. She said she was fired for being James Comey's daughter, for her perceived politics, or both, AP reported.
  • On Monday, U.S. District Judge Jesse Furman ruled for her. He found the firing broke the Civil Service Reform Act of 1978 and her Fifth Amendment due-process rights, AP and CBS reported.
  • The DOJ had argued the president has unlimited power to remove prosecutors. Furman said the attorney general can remove them only within that law's rules. He said one DOJ argument "borders on frivolous," CNBC reported.
  • Back pay runs from July 16 to Dec. 20, 2025, when the judge found she had likely taken another job, CNBC reported. The reports we read gave no dollar figure.
  • Outlets differ on what comes next. NPR said she may return as a prosecutor "if she chooses." The Daily Caller, citing Reuters, said she is not seeking to return.
  • The DOJ said it will "appeal in due course." Her First Amendment claim is still open, with filings due Nov. 9. Furman did not rule on whether her family tie caused the firing, AP reported.

How each side told it

The left led with the ruling and the job. NBC News ran: "Judge orders DOJ to reinstate former federal prosecutor Maurene Comey, daughter of ex-FBI director." NBC quoted Furman first, in paragraph 3, and gave the DOJ's appeal plan in paragraph 5. It named her four lawyers in paragraph 6. The New Republic called the ruling a "Massive Loss" for Trump. NBC did not say the order is not final, a point NPR made. NBC also left out which president appointed Furman. AP and CBS left that out too.

What got buried

The DOJ's own concessions sat low. The department admitted the firing was not for cause and not about her work, CNBC reported in paragraphs 18 and 19. It also admitted she got none of the required procedural protections. CBS said the DOJ conceded she was rated "outstanding" from 2019 to 2024, in paragraph 18. In the seven reports we read, only CNBC and CBS carried these points. The right-leaning reports gave that space to the judge's background. NBC and AP did not carry them either.

Why it matters to you

This case tests how far a president can go in firing career prosecutors. The DOJ argued the Constitution gives unlimited removal power. Furman said that theory "flies in the face of nearly two centuries of Supreme Court precedent," the Daily Wire reported. The back pay covers about five months, from July 16 to Dec. 20, 2025. The order is not final yet, NPR reported, so an appeal cannot start. If you follow the case, the next date is Nov. 9, when filings on her First Amendment claim are due.

Concessions in a court filing say more than headlines do.

All coverage

What we read to write this

Discussion

Be specific. Disagree with the framing, not the person.
Commenting is part of Pro. See Pro

Loading the discussion.