Every side of every story, in your inbox by 7am.Subscribe
Theme
Appearance
Subscribe

Appeals court won't make California set aside 20,000 ballots the DOJ calls suspect

A 9th Circuit panel ruled 2-1 on jurisdiction and called the DOJ's emergency partly self-made. The case returns to a district judge on Tuesday.

19 outlets24 headlines3 min read
Image: Associated Press

The story

A federal appeals court on Monday, Oct. 26, refused the Justice Department's bid to make California set aside about 20,000 mail ballots. The 2-1 ruling was about procedure. It did not decide whether anyone voted illegally.

  • The DOJ sued California election officials on Oct. 15. It said the state missed a 48-hour deadline to review a list of 20,000 people the DOJ called likely noncitizens, AP reported.
  • The DOJ said it built the list from voter rolls, commercial data, and immigration and Social Security records, Breitbart reported.
  • The list is disputed. Los Angeles County staff checked 200 records. They found inactive registrations and voters who appeared to be U.S.-born, AP reported. A DHS sworn statement said none in the sample were U.S.-born, Breitbart reported.
  • The DOJ asked the district court to rule by Oct. 22. When no ruling came, it appealed. The 9th Circuit heard arguments over Zoom on Sunday, Oct. 25, CNN reported.
  • On Monday the panel dismissed the appeal for lack of jurisdiction. Judges Mark Bennett, a Trump appointee, and Gabriel Sanchez, a Biden appointee, formed the majority. Judge Patrick Bumatay, a Trump appointee, dissented.
  • The majority said the DOJ had given the lower court about 15 hours to rule, Fox 11 Los Angeles reported. Sanchez wrote that the emergency was "the product of the United States's own decisions," AP reported.
  • The same day, the DOJ asked Washington state to set aside ballots from more than 400 voters, AP reported.
  • The case goes back to a district judge on Tuesday, Oct. 27. The appeals court did not rule on the merits, CNN reported.

How each side told it

The left led with the rejection and the court's own words. CNN ran: "Appeals court rejects Trump DOJ demand to set aside 20,000 California mail ballots." Its second paragraph called the suit part of a push to expand federal power over elections. CNN gave paragraphs 15 to 28 to the hearing. There, DOJ lawyer Matthew Donnelly could not name the "third-party" data sources. California's lawyer called the data "wildly outdated." Bumatay's dissent got one line in paragraph 6. Politico ran: "Appeals court rejects DOJ's bid to quickly force California to set aside ballots."

What got buried

The track record of lists like this one sat low. AP's Washington state story gave two past cases, in paragraphs 13 and 14. In Nevada, an allegation about 1,500 people led to zero cases. In Maricopa County, Arizona, 207 claimed possible noncitizens became 8. AP's California story called noncitizen voting "exceedingly rare" in paragraph 3. The DOJ also said some people on its Washington list may have since become citizens. Neither CNN nor the right-leaning reports we read carried the Nevada or Maricopa figures.

Why it matters to you

If you vote by mail in California, this case decides whether some ballots get counted on time. Los Angeles County had processed more than 331,000 mail ballots before Oct. 22, Fox 11 reported. The Maricopa figures show how such lists can shrink. 8 out of 207 is about 4%. That number comes from Arizona, so it may not carry over to California. Gov. Gavin Newsom called the ruling a "welcome speed bump." Bumatay wrote that the government "has an interest in stopping the illegal voting in the first place." A district judge hears the case Tuesday, with little time left before Nov. 3, AP said.

Read what a court decided before reading what it means.

All coverage

What we read to write this

Discussion

Be specific. Disagree with the framing, not the person.
Commenting is part of Pro. See Pro

Loading the discussion.