Every side of every story, in your inbox by 7am.Subscribe
Theme
Appearance
Subscribe

Poll finds 22% of 2024 Trump voters now disapprove, and profiles ran mostly on the left

AP followed a Texas cancer patient who voted Democrat for the first time. Two left-leaning sites rewrote a Washington Post poll story on voters who soured.

5 outlets6 headlines3 min read
Image: Associated Press (via Anchorage Daily News)

The story

About 1 in 5 people who voted for Trump in 2024 now disapprove of him, a Post-ABC-Ipsos poll found. Five outlets in our list ran stories on those voters on Oct. 25, and none of them leans right.

  • AP profiled Cindy Banda, 46, a single mother in McAllen, Texas, who has breast cancer.
  • She voted for Trump in 2016, 2020 and 2024, AP reported. Her main reason was her opposition to abortion.
  • She now has more than $25,000 in medical debt and a $7,500 deductible, AP reported.
  • She cast an early ballot for Democrat James Talarico over Republican Ken Paxton for Senate. She texted that she had never voted Democrat before that day.
  • The Washington Post ran a wider story on Trump voters who changed their minds. We could not load it. Raw Story and the Daily Beast both rewrote it.
  • Per those rewrites, 22% of 2024 Trump voters now disapprove of him. The Daily Beast said that is about 8% of the electorate.
  • Raw Story reported that 76% of Trump voters who still approve are certain to vote or already have. Among those who disapprove, the share is 53%.
  • Not every unhappy voter is switching. Amy Reese, 42, of Victoria, Virginia, said she will never vote Democrat, Raw Story reported.

How each side told it

The left led with the voters who left. The Washington Post ran: "These Trump voters changed their minds." The Daily Beast and Raw Story rewrote the Post story with hotter words. The Daily Beast ran: "Trump Faces Revolt From Voters Who Backed Him Three Times." Its first paragraph called Trump the "80-year-old president." Raw Story ran: "'I fell for it three times': Furious Trump voters threaten to sink GOP in midterms." Raw Story kept voters who still back Republicans, like Dana Bessen, 76, in paragraph 13. The Daily Beast left them out in the version we read.

What got buried

The health cost worry came from a right-leaning pollster. AP cited a Fox News poll from September in paragraph 4. About half of registered voters called health care costs a major problem, it said. Four years earlier, a little more than one-third did. Fox's own poll measured the worry this story is built on. It did not appear in the right-leaning headlines we saw that day. Raw Story carried another cost detail in paragraph 11. Reese said her electric bill was almost $700 last month and her insulin cost more than doubled.

Why it matters to you

Here is the turnout math from the Post poll, as Raw Story reported it. 76% of approving Trump voters are certain to vote. 53% of disapproving ones are. That is a 23-point gap. So the unhappy group is less likely to show up. Raw Story's profiles show some plan to sit out, and some plan to back other Republicans. Banda's deductible was $7,500, AP reported, and her bills changed her vote. If health costs drive your choice, the AP poll numbers show many voters share that worry. The reports we read don't show how this group will vote on Nov. 3.

Who a story profiles shapes how a poll feels.

All coverage

What we read to write this

Discussion

Be specific. Disagree with the framing, not the person.
Commenting is part of Pro. See Pro

Loading the discussion.