Every side of every story, in your inbox by 7am.Subscribe
Theme
Appearance
Subscribe

Justice Department defends suit to hold Alaska Senate results if Sen. Sullivan loses

Todd Blanche said on CNN the suit guards against voter confusion between two Sullivans on the ballot. Murkowski and Peltola criticized it.

15 outlets21 headlines3 min read
Image: Fox News

The story

The Justice Department sued to stop Alaska from certifying its Senate race if Republican Sen. Dan Sullivan loses. On Oct. 25, Todd Blanche defended the suit on CNN, nine days before the Nov. 3 vote.

  • The department sued late Thursday in federal court in Alaska, NPR reported. Associate Attorney General Stanley Woodward signed it.
  • The case is about two men named Sullivan on the ballot. One is the Republican senator. The other, Daniel J. Sullivan Jr. of Petersburg, has no party listed, AP reported.
  • The suit cites the National Voter Registration Act, NPR reported. It asks the state not to certify results that "may be impacted by voter confusion."
  • Trump said: "I'm the one that said do it," NPR and Fox News reported.
  • On CNN's "State of the Union," Blanche said: "We are not doing anything improper," AP reported. He said the suit does not tell the state to skip certifying.
  • Sen. Lisa Murkowski, a Republican, said the state already tells the two men apart, NPR reported. Democrat Mary Peltola called the suit "flagrant, flagrant corruption in my opinion," AP reported.
  • Peltola's campaign moved to join the case, Fox News reported. The reports we read don't say which judge has it.

How each side told it

The left led with what the suit would block. NPR ran: "Blanche defends DOJ lawsuit blocking Alaska Senate results if Republican loses." Its second paragraph went to an earlier Blanche remark about a "doomsday" certification scenario. HuffPost went with Trump's mood: "Trump Seethes Over GOP's 'Worst Senator' Who Knocked His DOJ's Lawsuit." Politico put Blanche's own words up top: "There could be a crime." NPR named the law behind the suit in paragraph 17 of the version we read. On the left, certification came first and the two names on the ballot came second.

What got buried

Two details sat low. The first is size. In the August primary, the senator got more than 68,000 votes and the other Sullivan got 4,107, NPR reported. Of the 4 reports we read, only NPR gave those numbers, in paragraph 21. The second is the ballot itself. AP reported in paragraph 9 that it lists "Dan S. Sullivan" as the Republican incumbent. It lists "Daniel J. Sullivan Jr." with no party. The whole suit turns on whether voters mix up those two lines.

Why it matters to you

Here is the primary math, from NPR's numbers. The other Sullivan got 4,107 of about 72,107 votes cast for the two Sullivans. That is under 6%. The Washington Examiner reported the Sullivan-Peltola race is within single digits and rated a toss-up. In a close race, a share that size could matter. The reports we read don't say how many of those votes were mistakes. Certification is the step that makes a count official. If you vote in Alaska on Nov. 3, check the party line next to each Sullivan name. The label is printed on the ballot.

A close race turns every footnote into a headline.

All coverage

What we read to write this

Discussion

Be specific. Disagree with the framing, not the person.
Commenting is part of Pro. See Pro

Loading the discussion.