Appeals judges question DOJ bid to set aside 20,000 California mail ballots
At a rare Sunday hearing, two of three 9th Circuit judges pressed the Justice Department on its request to hold ballots of suspected noncitizens.

The story
A federal appeals panel held a rare Sunday hearing on Oct. 25 over 20,000 California mail ballots. Two of the three judges sounded doubtful of the Justice Department's request to set them aside, AP reported.
- The Justice Department sued California on Oct. 15, Fox News reported. That was about two weeks after ballots started going out.
- It sent the state a list of 20,000 people it calls likely noncitizens, Reuters reported. It wants their ballots kept apart until citizenship is checked.
- AP reported the department says California missed a 48-hour deadline to review the names.
- District Judge David Carter did not rule by the department's deadline, Fox reported. The department then went to the 9th Circuit.
- Judge Mark Bennett, a Trump appointee, said: "It seems to me that you want us to issue an injunction." Judge Gabriel Sanchez, a Biden appointee, also pressed the government. Judge Patrick Bumatay, a Trump appointee, was the most open to its case, AP reported.
- Sam Siegel, a lawyer for Secretary of State Shirley Weber, said: "It has no basis in law or in fact."
- The reports we read don't say when the panel would rule.
How each side told it
The left led with the judges' doubts. CNN ran: "Judges skeptical of Trump administration effort to force California to set aside mail ballots." NBC News, running a Reuters report, went with "appears skeptical." Its second paragraph framed the case as part of a federal push into elections before Nov. 3. It named Bennett as a Trump appointee by paragraph 4. The Los Angeles Times put the number up top: "block 20,000 California ballots." All three headlines named Trump or "the feds" as the side under question. NBC put the rarity of noncitizen voting in paragraph 7.
What got buried
The best test of the list sat in one report. Los Angeles County checked 200 of the flagged records, AP reported. It found canceled or inactive registrations, people with no voting history, and voters who seemed to be born in the US. That came from a court filing by assistant registrar-recorder Monica Flores. In the 3 reports we read, only AP had this sample. NBC's Reuters report said noncitizen voting is "exceedingly rare," citing 129 federal cases. Fox carried neither detail in the version we read.
Why it matters to you
Start with size. 20,000 ballots out of more than 3 million already cast is under 1%, using Fox's statewide count. The workload is the other side. County lawyers said checking 2.75 million Los Angeles mail ballots at 3 minutes each would take about 140,000 hours, AP reported. Justice Department lawyer Matthew Donnelly argued the opposite risk: "The damage is irreversible and irrevocable." If you vote by mail in California, your ballot could be held if a court sided with the department. Seth Waxman, a lawyer for the county clerk, said that would disenfranchise eligible voters, AP reported.
A big number reads differently next to its total.
All coverage
Federal appeals court hears arguments in Trump administration's voting lawsuit against California
Judges skeptical of Trump administration effort to force California to set aside mail ballots
9th Circuit panel questions basis for feds’ request to block 20,000 California ballots
U.S. appeals court appears skeptical of Trump DOJ’s lawsuit over California voter rolls
Justice Department faces skeptical appeals court panel in California ballot fight
9th Circuit questions DOJ demand to set aside 20,000 California mail ballots
Trump’s Voter Fraud Show Comes to California
Ninth Circuit questions Trump DOJ's emergency request to set aside 20,000 California mail ballots
What we read to write this
- Associated Press (via ClickOnDetroit) 9th Circuit questions DOJ demand to set aside 20,000 California mail ballots
- Fox News Ninth Circuit questions Trump DOJ's emergency request to set aside 20,000 California mail ballots
- NBC News (Reuters) U.S. appeals court appears skeptical of Trump DOJ's lawsuit over California voter rolls
Loading the discussion.