Every side of every story, in your inbox by 7am.Subscribe
Theme
Appearance
Subscribe

Obama holds his first midterm rallies in Cleveland and Detroit, 10 days before the vote

Nineteen outlets covered it. The left led with 'cruelty.' The right led with a Cheesecake Factory joke and Obama's own record.

19 outlets26 headlines3 min read
Image: Associated Press (via Anchorage Daily News)

The story

Barack Obama spoke for 35 minutes in Cleveland on Oct 24, NBC News reported. Nineteen outlets in our set covered his first midterm rallies, and they led with different lines from the same speech.

  • On Saturday, Oct 24, Obama held his first rally of the midterms in Cleveland, NBC News reported.
  • He backed Amy Acton for Ohio governor and Sherrod Brown for Senate against Sen. Jon Husted, AP and NBC reported. NBC called both Ohio races toss-ups.
  • In Cleveland, Obama spoke of "chaos and cruelty and corruption and incompetence," AP reported. He also called Congress "spineless."
  • On the White House renovations, he said Trump "should be on HGTV." He said Trump has the White House "looking like Saddam Hussein opened a Cheesecake Factory," Fox News reported.
  • Later that day he spoke in Detroit for Abdul El-Sayed for Senate and Jocelyn Benson for governor, Michigan Public reported. It was Michigan's first day of in-person early voting.
  • On attacks aimed at El-Sayed's faith, Obama said: "We have seen this movie before. I starred in it."
  • On Monday, Oct 26, Trump answered at Joint Base Andrews. He said the joke "shows why you were a lousy president," ZeroHedge reported.
  • Outlets worded the joke three ways. Fox's headline says "opening," its quote says "opened," and an earlier Fox paragraph says "run by."

How each side told it

The left led with cruelty. NBC News ran: "Obama describes Trump as an agent of 'chaos and cruelty' in midterm elections pitch." NBC put the Cheesecake Factory joke in paragraph 4 and the crowd size in paragraph 5. It gave paragraphs 9 to 16 to a fight over a Vivek Ramaswamy ad. Obama's lines on tariffs and the Iran war came in paragraphs 26 and 27, out of 31. Michigan got one line, in paragraph 28. Politico ran: "Obama slams Ramaswamy and Trump in his first rally of the midterms." So the left told an Ohio story about tone, with prices near the bottom.

What got buried

Obama's argument about money sat low on both sides. He tied rising prices to tariffs and the Iran war, NBC reported in paragraphs 26 and 27. The AP report we read did not mention tariffs. Fox gave Iran paragraphs 12 to 17, mostly as a recap of the 2015 nuclear deal and Trump's 2018 exit from it. One more number sat at the bottom. Obama has helped raise more than $15 million and recorded more than two dozen TV and radio ads, NBC said in paragraph 30. In the five reports we read, only NBC carried it. In our set, only the New York Post's headline named tariffs.

Why it matters to you

Ten days out, most of what you saw from these rallies was one joke. The Cheesecake Factory line ran in headlines from Newsweek, The Hill, CNN, Fox News and Raw Story. Obama's pitch to voters was also about prices, NBC reported. That part touches your grocery bill and your gas tank. The reports we read don't say how much tariffs or the war added to prices. Fox, for its part, gave readers numbers on Obama's own building project, $1 billion against $350 million. Each side picked the cost it wanted you to see. You can ask every candidate for a number on prices, then check it.

The funniest line travels farthest, and the argument stays home.

All coverage

What we read to write this

Discussion

Be specific. Disagree with the framing, not the person.
Commenting is part of Pro. See Pro

Loading the discussion.