Justice Department tells California counties to set aside ballots from suspected noncitizens
The letters cover about 20,000 voters, AP reported. A Los Angeles check of 200 names found nearly 4 in 10 were born in the US.

The story
The Justice Department asked California counties for data on about 20,000 voters it says are likely noncitizens, AP reported. It gave them 48 hours.
- Letters sent Friday, Oct 23, told county registrars to set aside ballots from suspected noncitizens, AP reported. They asked for data including Social Security numbers.
- The LA Times said 57 of 58 counties got letters, citing a spokesman. Its own first paragraph said "more than a dozen."
- Napa County got 42 names, delivered by two Homeland Security officers, AP reported. Santa Cruz County got 81, the LA Times reported.
- The Justice Department sued California on Oct 15. A federal appeals court then ordered the state to respond by noon Saturday, Fox News reported.
- Justice Department spokesperson Kiersten Pels said it is not seeking a "purge, cancellation of registrations, or any programmatic action," AP reported.
- Federal prosecutor Bill Essayli said officials who knowingly process such ballots face "legal jeopardy."
- Napa registrar John Tuteur said: "We're not changing anything we're doing."
- None of the reports we read explained how the list was built.
How each side told it
The left led with local officials. The LA Times ran: "'This is not normal': Feds demand California counties set aside 'likely' noncitizen ballots." That quote came from Santa Cruz clerk Tricia Webber. Her full line, in the body, was "This is not normal protocol for us." The Times gave its first quote, "aiders and abettors," to the Justice Department and Trump in paragraph 5. Local voices started at paragraph 11. HuffPost ran the AP headline: "California Election Officials Frustrated, Rattled By DOJ Demand." AP led with officials being "confused and frustrated." It called noncitizen voting "rare" in paragraph 2.
What got buried
The results of past checks sat at the very bottom. Los Angeles County checked 200 names from the federal list, AP reported. More than 40% had cancelled registrations. Over 70% had no voting history. Nearly 4 in 10 were born in the US. AP put this in its last paragraph. The LA Times put a shorter version in its last paragraph. Fox and TheBlaze left it out. AP also reported, in paragraph 21, that a Nevada claim of 1,500 noncitizen voters turned up zero.
Why it matters to you
If you vote by mail in California, your ballot goes through a county registrar. Those are the offices getting these letters. Here is the sample math. Nearly 4 in 10 of 200 names is close to 80 people born in the US, from one county's check. The reports we read don't say if that rate holds for the full list. Twenty-eight people from the list were charged in a sweep, AP reported. In Minnesota, 10 people were charged across three elections with more than 8 million ballots, AP added. You can confirm your own registration on your county's election site.
A list is a claim until someone checks the names.
All coverage
California Election Officials Frustrated, Rattled By DOJ Demand To Sequester 'Noncitizen' Ballots
‘This is not normal’: Feds demand California counties set aside ‘likely’ noncitizen ballots
California election officials frustrated, rattled by DOJ demand to sequester 'noncitizen' ballots
Trump administration demands California expose suspected 'noncitizen' voters in major escalation of crackdown on eve of midterms
California must respond to DOJ's emergency request over ballots mailed to alleged noncitizens, court rules
California says ‘trust us’ on voter eligibility. Why?
What we read to write this
- Associated Press (via PBS NewsHour) California election officials frustrated, rattled by DOJ demand to sequester 'noncitizen' ballots
- Fox News California must respond to DOJ's emergency request over ballots mailed to alleged noncitizens, court rules
- Los Angeles Times (reprint) Feds demand California counties set aside 'likely' noncitizen ballots
- TheBlaze California says 'trust us' on voter eligibility. Why?
Loading the discussion.