Every side of every story, in your inbox by 7am.Subscribe
Theme
Appearance
Subscribe

Cook Political Report moves 19 House races toward Democrats, sees 12 to 22 seat gain

Eleven days before Election Day, the forecaster said Republicans' path to keeping the House has 'all but evaporated.' No race moved toward Republicans.

8 outlets8 headlines2 min read Blindspot for the left
Image: The Daily Caller

The story

The Cook Political Report shifted 19 House races toward Democrats on Oct. 23. It projected Democrats would gain 12 to 22 seats, up from 9 to 19 two weeks earlier.

  • Cook's update came 11 days before the Nov. 3 election. Analyst Erin Covey wrote it, Newsweek reported.
  • Cook wrote that Republicans' path to keeping the House "has all but evaporated." It said Democrats are now favored in the 218 seats needed for control. It rated 17 races as pure toss-ups.
  • Races moving from Toss Up to Lean Democrat included Arizona's 6th, Colorado's 8th, Virginia's 2nd and Wisconsin's 3rd, the Daily Caller reported. Republicans hold all four.
  • Rep. Lauren Boebert's Colorado seat also moved toward Democrats. Trump won it by 18 points, the Daily Caller reported. No race moved toward Republicans, Newsweek reported.
  • A DCCC spokesperson credited a "relentless focus on lowering costs." The NRCC did not respond to Newsweek.
  • The House is now 218 Republicans to 214 Democrats, Newsweek reported. Outlets gave different counts of seats leaning Democratic: 218, 219 or 220.

How each side told it

One left-leaning outlet in our list ran the Cook update: The Washington Post. Its headline said Democrats were "poised for significant House gains." A later version we found led with the range: "Democrats may flip between 12 and 22 seats." We could not load the story, so we can't say whom it quoted first. Other left outlets told the House outlook through people instead. MS NOW ran Kevin McCarthy saying the GOP is "going to lose." CNN ran Mike Johnson asking Trump for more midterm money.

What got buried

Two details sat low. The first is the money. The Daily Caller reported in paragraph 14 that the Congressional Leadership Fund pulled $6 million from a Florida race. It said the group moved $9 million to six Republican-held seats. Of the two reports we read, Newsweek did not mention it. The second is a caution about polls. Newsweek said in paragraph 27 that generic-ballot polls have overstated Democrats in past cycles. The Daily Caller did not mention polls at all.

Why it matters to you

Cook's range of 12 to 22 seats would give Democrats 227 to 237 seats, Newsweek reported. A majority is 218. At the low end, that is 9 seats to spare. At the high end, it is 19. Newsweek cited generic-ballot polls ranging from Democrats up 5 points (Echelon Insights, Oct. 15 to 19) to up 11 points (NYT/Siena, Oct. 12 to 19). A rating is an analyst's read of the odds. When you see a forecast headline, look for the range, since Cook's spans 10 seats.

A forecast is a range, and headlines often quote one end.

All coverage

What we read to write this

Discussion

Be specific. Disagree with the framing, not the person.
Commenting is part of Pro. See Pro

Loading the discussion.