Russia frees American Stephen Hubbard as Witkoff meets Putin and talks restart
Hubbard, 74, left Russia after more than four years in custody. Witkoff's praise for Putin drew Republican criticism, and the Kremlin agreed to new talks.

The story
Russia freed Stephen Hubbard, a 74-year-old former teacher from Michigan, on Oct. 21 after more than four years in custody, AP reported. Trump said the US gave nothing in return, and a later post of his tied the talks to a sanctions waiver.
- Russia released Hubbard on Wednesday, Oct. 21, while US envoy Steve Witkoff visited St. Petersburg, AP reported.
- Russian troops took Hubbard from his home in Izyum, Ukraine, in April 2022, the Daily Wire reported. A closed Russian court convicted him in 2024 of fighting as a mercenary for Ukraine. AP said the sentence was nearly seven years. Hubbard denies the charges, NBC reported.
- Trump said he asked Putin by phone the week before. He wrote that the US "was not required to give anything in return," Fox News reported.
- Witkoff told Putin, "You are a humanitarian also, sir," AP reported. Kremlin spokesman Dmitry Peskov said Putin acted on "humanitarian considerations."
- Putin also agreed "in principle" to restart three-way talks with Ukraine and the US after Nov. 10, Kremlin adviser Yuri Ushakov said, per AP. The meeting ran about three hours.
- Hubbard landed at Lackland Air Force Base in Texas late Wednesday, NBC reported.
- The reports we read don't say what, if anything, Russia asked for in private.
How each side told it
The left led with Witkoff's words. CBS News ran: "Witkoff faces backlash for calling Putin a 'humanitarian': 'Embarrassing and outrageous.'" It quoted five Republican lawmakers in paragraphs 6 to 11, among them Sen. Thom Tillis and Sen. Susan Collins. NBC News ran: "Retired American teacher imprisoned by Russia returns to U.S." Its third paragraph carried the "humanitarian" line, and Collins's criticism followed in paragraph 4. NBC did not mention Biden, Hubbard's sentence or his sister's account in the version we read. The left told the story of the envoy. The prisoner came second.





Trump Admits He Made Huge Concession to Free American in RussiaThe New Republic
Vladimir Putin, the HumanitarianThe Atlantic

Russia frees U.S. citizen as Kremlin maneuvers to show goodwill to TrumpThe Washington Post
What got buried
Two details sat low. The first is Trump's own words. NBC reported in paragraph 28 of 34 that Trump said the Hubbard talks would have stopped if he had not waived sanctions. Fox touched the same point in paragraph 6. AP and CBS named the waiver without that link, and the Daily Wire left it out. The second is Hubbard's treatment. His sister wrote in August that he suffered "constant beatings, torture and starvation," AP reported in its final paragraphs. No one has confirmed those claims independently. In the six reports we read, the "nothing in return" line always ran higher than the sanctions post.
Why it matters to you
If you have family held abroad, this case shows how releases work right now. Hubbard was the last American in Russia the State Department labeled "wrongfully detained," NBC reported. He is the second American Russia freed in about two months, after Robert Gilman in August, AP said. Eric Lebson of Global Reach said "there are five other families of Americans held in Russia," AP reported. The same week, AP reported, Trump waived sanctions under a Russia bill Congress passed and announced a deal to import Russian diesel. Those are policy choices, made alongside a prisoner case. You can watch the date Ushakov gave, Nov. 10. That is the next test of what this visit produced.
The first quote in a story often picks its hero.
All coverage
Witkoff lauds 'humanitarian' Putin as Russia releases detained American
Witkoff faces backlash for calling Putin a "humanitarian": "Embarrassing and outrageous"
Russia frees American Stephen Hubbard after more than 4 years behind bars
Republicans criticize Trump’s envoy calling Putin ‘a humanitarian’ after releasing American
Oct. 21: Why Russia Released an American Prisoner; How a Viral Attack Is Rattling an Ohio Race
Trump Admits He Made Huge Concession to Free American in Russia
Russia releases imprisoned U.S. citizen Stephen Hubbard following Trump's request
Vladimir Putin, the Humanitarian
Putin orders release of jailed American as he meets Trump envoy for Ukraine talks | Russia
Russia released a US prisoner. What did they get out of it?
Russia frees U.S. citizen as Kremlin maneuvers to show goodwill to Trump
Russia agrees to resume three-way talks on Ukraine war with Kyiv and Washington, Kremlin says
Putin tells Witkoff he is ready to resume direct peace talks, Russia releases U.S. detainee
Russia-Ukraine war update: President Vladimir Putin meet Donald Trump special envoy Steve Witkoff on how to end conflict wit Ukraine
Russia Frees American Prisoner Held Since 2022 As Trump Envoy Meets Putin
Putin agrees to resume 3-way peace talks with Ukraine and US
Russia Relents: Frees American Citizen Stephen Hubbard After Trump Pressure
Russia frees US prisoner Stephen Hubbard as Trump claims Putin asked nothing in return 'out of respect for me'
Putin Agrees To Three-Way Ukraine Peace Talks After Meeting With Trump Envoys
Will Thibeau analyzes Steven Witkoff's Russia peace talks, Stephen Hubbard's release
Russia releases detained American Stephen Hubbard following Witkoff's Putin meeting
Trump Envoy Steve Witkoff Calls Putin a ‘Humanitarian’ During Meeting in Moscow
Russia 'Ready' to Resume Trilateral Talks, but Cool on Ukraine Deal
Trump celebrates US prisoner Stephen Hubbard’s release from Russia - as Witkoff shares first freedom pics
Trump Successfully Requests American Prisoner Be Freed From Russia
What we read to write this
- Associated Press (via PBS NewsHour) Russia frees American Stephen Hubbard after over 4 years in prison, during a visit from U.S. envoy Witkoff
- Associated Press (via KOLD) Russia agrees to resume three-way talks on Ukraine war with Kyiv and Washington, Kremlin says
- NBC News Russia frees American Stephen Hubbard as Trump envoy meets with Putin
- CBS News Witkoff faces backlash for calling Putin a 'humanitarian': 'Embarrassing and outrageous'
- Fox News Russia releases American teacher imprisoned on Ukraine mercenary charges after Trump pressed Putin
- The Daily Wire Trump Persuades Putin To Free Jailed American Teacher Who Was Taken On Biden's Watch
Loading the discussion.